Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Howells of St Davids (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 26 November 2009. It occurred during Queen's speech debate on Queen’s Speech.


Queen’s Speech

My Lords, I, too, offer my congratulations to the noble Lord, Lord Sacks. I should like to crave his indulgence in the future should I attend any of the classes that he proposes. As someone who has had decades of experience in promoting race equality, I have a special interest in the Equality Bill and its provisions. However, today I will concentrate on a provision that is much needed in that Bill but has been left out. My suspicion is that there is little or no concern in the Bill for tackling the institutional racism that is still inherent in British society, as evidenced so vividly by the resurgence of support that the BNP has received in this country and in Europe. While I accept that the BNP’s status will always remain as a minority party, my concern is that the Aryan myth of white superiority that underpins it is alive and well among many more than those who vote for that party. These myths and beliefs translate into action in competitive situations with a crucial impact on the life chances of black people. They do so now but, unlike in the past, there are more subtle and insidious ways in which they rear their ugly head. Discrimination is now buried in phrases like, "Employers want to hire the best person for the job". No one, black or white, would disagree. However, the invariable outcome would lead to the illogical conclusion that no black person could ever succeed in any labour market when the competition is with a white person, especially for management posts. Does the Bill before us equip us to engage practically, positively and decisively with such an environment? I think not. The Bill uses the term "as qualified"; the guidance notes use "equally qualified". I am ashamed to say that I heard one of my honourable colleagues speak of "equally acceptable" as a criterion when seeking to establish the principles of equality. When a black person is "equally acceptable", what does that mean—and in what way, in the context of the Aryan myth? Above all, will the Bill prove more effective than the Race Relations Act in allowing black people to prove that they were discriminated against? Will it also allow them to access the professional legal resources necessary to obtain justice through the judicial system? I suspect not. I find the Bill not fit for purpose in this area; I think that the words would be "a paper tiger". The belief that the tribunal system is a quick and easy solution for redress for a person who feels that they have been discriminated against is false and erroneous. Companies involved in such litigation have access to skilled professional practitioners experienced in the use of procedure, artful in interrogative techniques and sophisticated in adversarial encounters. Unleashed, they would terrify all but a minuscule number of confident and equally sophisticated complainants. Most black people would have to fend for themselves alone and unaided. Experience at a tribunal can therefore often achieve the reverse of its intention, by further aggravating the distress suffered and leaving the individual doubting the authenticity of the discrimination that they suffered. I have seen that happen time and time again. I suggest that the Equality Bill needs to be reconsidered and to have installed within it representative actions in all such cases of racial discrimination. This approach is not novel to government. It would put a brake on the number of cases and reduce the professional costs of bringing actions and the time and cost of the tribunal system. Only then will I feel that the ambitions enshrined in the Bill might in any way be met.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
715 c497-8 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Children Curriculum Age Equality Health services Fees and charges Equal pay Discrimination Home care services Home education NHS Recruitment Poverty Primary education Personal, social, health and economic education Schools
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk