Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Turner of Camden (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 26 November 2009. It occurred during Queen's speech debate on Queen’s Speech.


Queen’s Speech

My Lords, I welcome the opportunity to participate in what is proving to be a very wide-ranging debate, with, of course, two really quite remarkable maiden speeches. I am glad that the Equality Bill heads the agenda. I was, for a number of years, a member of the EOC—the Equal Opportunities Commission—at a time when the noble Baroness, Lady Platt, was chair of the commission. A campaign which was introduced at that time, and which I still think was important, was the WISE campaign—Women into Science and Engineering. When I was young, I and the women of my generation left our schools and colleges steered in the direction of the sort of jobs thought suitable for women—mainly in offices, or perhaps teaching or nursing—but we left education with very little knowledge of how things actually work. Happily, things have changed; I believe that the EOC’s campaign headed by the noble Baroness, Lady Platt, who had herself been a professional engineer, has played a substantial role in that, and I still think it is very important. The Equality Bill, which we will no doubt have the opportunity to discuss in detail when it is before the House, is designed to bring together the various legislative provisions across the whole spectrum of discrimination. I recall that when the notion emerged of the various commissions being made into one, I had my doubts as to whether a new body covering the whole spectrum would be successful. I am still not entirely sure, but I can understand why the Government should have decided to proceed as they have with an Equality Bill designed to ensure that all our citizens should have the right to a free and equal life, and for that they are to be commended. As far as gender equality is concerned, some problems still remain, and this the Government have identified. There is still a substantial disparity between male and female earnings. It is understood that this may take some time to deal with, but at least it has been recognised. We now have a legal framework providing rights for women, but we should not forget that this has taken many years to establish and previous generations of women have fought very hard indeed to attain what many now take for granted. But that is the law—culture is often very different. We are rightly proud that we are a very diverse culture; but while other cultures and religions are entitled to respect, our laws must take absolute precedence. Some cultures rely on interpretations of their religion to impose unequal status amounting to repression of women. Attempts are made to deny the right to work, to education, to form relationships, to dress as women wish, to play a part in public life; but women have rights that cannot be denied to them for family or religious reasons. Many women caught up in this so-called culture want to escape from it even though they may be threatened with violence. We must do whatever we can to help them, appreciating how very difficult it must be for them if they face repression within the family. Another area where substantial progress has been made during the period of the present Government is in relation to discrimination on grounds of sexual orientation. There has also been a very long campaign to secure protection against discrimination for gay and lesbian people—but it is now unlawful to discriminate on those grounds. Again, there is a cultural problem. Again, those who would like to discriminate often do so by citing a religious reason for so doing. Of course there is a right to criticise, if people want to do so, but all too often the right to criticise can escalate into incitement to violence. Homophobic violence is, sadly, on the increase, some of it horrific. We have good, humane laws. We must ensure that these are applied and that those who seek to harass and threaten are speedily dealt with. The Bill does seek to deal with harassment. The right to free speech should not serve as a reason to indulge in threatening behaviour against those whose orientation may displease certain individuals who claim that it affronts their religious views. As far as religion is concerned, I note that attempts are being made in the Bill to ensure that the management of faith schools, or indeed other religious employers, may not insist that all their employees must be adherents of the particular religion involved. There are, however, to be some exceptions. I hope there will be an opportunity to examine this further when the Bill is finally before us. I can think of no circumstances where any employer would be entitled to make a ruling in regard to the religion or sexual orientation of any individual employee. Finally, I would like to take this opportunity of congratulating the Government on seeking to deal with the problem of social care of the elderly. Again, we shall no doubt have the opportunity to debate this in more detail when the legislation is before this House. Nowadays, many elderly and infirm people live alone; social changes have been responsible for this. Most would prefer to remain living at home. Care homes are often a last resort. Not only are they often very expensive, recent research indicates that they are often not well run and elderly people suffer in them. There was a case reported even last week of an elderly man who had been allowed to die of neglect in a care home. I understand from the press that several of my noble friends have been critical of what the Government are proposing. I think that those who hold that sort of view can have had little experience of looking after older people. I have had a great deal of experience, in my own family and also with friends. My own mother, when she was ill, begged me not to put her in a home. She wanted to stay in her own home, and I had to promise that that would be her situation, and she was never sent into a care home. I have had other elderly relatives who felt exactly the same as she did. I was my late husband's carer. In the last few years of his life, he was on dialysis. He certainly did not want to go into a home, and he did not. I do not know why my noble friends feel as they do. I hope it is not a matter of cost. We must not plead cost as the reason for not looking after elderly people in a humane and sensitive way. We also need to ensure that local authorities are provided with the resources to keep records of the elderly and infirm people in their locality and can provide assistance when this is necessary. There must be an obligation—a responsibility—for this service to be provided. We shall no doubt return to this when the Bill is before us, but, in the mean time, I fully support what the Government are doing.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
715 c521-3 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Children Curriculum Age Equality Health services Fees and charges Equal pay Discrimination Home care services Home education NHS Recruitment Poverty Primary education Personal, social, health and economic education Schools
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk