Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Warwick of Undercliffe (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 26 November 2009. It occurred during Queen's speech debate on Queen’s Speech.


Queen’s Speech

My Lords, I want to focus my remarks on the UK’s progress in becoming world-class in developing skills for employment and on the ways in which the Children, Schools and Families Bill and the Digital Economy Bill will take this forward. In my view, the Government have made huge strides over the past 12 years. The recent report from the UK Commission for Employment and Skills documents this well, but it also highlights that by international comparisons on skills, we are treading water—other countries are doing as well or even better. In the middle of a recession, we have to learn the lessons of the past. We must not cut our investment in learning and training. I echo Graham Bann of Business in the Community, who said: ""Investing in learning and training now … enables companies, enterprises and organisations to prepare themselves for when the market picks up again"." In different ways, both the Bills that I mentioned address the Government’s desire to ensure that the education system helps to equip the UK for the future and for the demands of the economy. The Children, Schools and Families Bill, we are told, will, ""introduce reforms to the school curriculum so children and young people are equipped with the knowledge and skills they, and future employers, want and need"." This will sit alongside a continuing focus on the basics of literacy, numeracy and information and communications technology. Meanwhile, the Digital Economy Bill takes forward the Digital Britain strategy by strengthening our digital infrastructure, recognising that this is vital for the UK’s success in every other area of productivity and for the UK’s position as one of the world’s leading digital knowledge economies. Although this Bill does not touch on education directly, elsewhere, including in the New Industry, New Jobs White Paper and the First Secretary’s Statement in this House on 11 November, the Government have recognised the need to ensure that the workforce is equipped to meet the demands of this rapidly growing part of the economy, including by supporting the education which underpins creative technologies. This strategy takes its cue from the influential 2006 report by my noble friend Lord Leitch. My noble friend’s report made a powerful case for the need to address the skills needs of the economy if we are to retain our seat at the table among the big eight economies of the world. This Government took office with a famous commitment to "education, education, education", and I think that we should note and applaud the fact that the same commitment is evident in this latest Loyal Address. In the area that I know best—higher education—there can be no doubt that the Government’s investment has produced a terrific success story. However, we should not underestimate how difficult it is to predict the skills needs of tomorrow. In the field of higher education, my experience of working with employers and their representatives has shown me that in most cases what employers want, certainly of higher education, is rarely specific competencies. That has been demonstrated most recently by the CBI in its two publications, Stronger Together and Future Fit, the last of which was produced in conjunction with Universities UK. I do not think that I need any longer declare an interest as I have retired from Universities UK and am now its former chief executive. Asked to define the "employability skills they value", employers point to generic skills. They include team-working, problem-solving and self-management. These are also the skills that will set an individual up for a lifetime of different jobs and roles. Collectively, they are an important ingredient in creating a flexible, adaptable workforce to staff a dynamic economy. This has never been more important. Even without the current global financial turbulence, the pace of change in response to global competition over the past decade or so points to the need for adaptable individuals to staff industries that have not yet been born. Indeed, the digital economy and the growing economic importance of the creative industries set an important example. Few people speaking 20 years ago would have predicted either their central importance to our current and future ability to generate wealth or the interdisciplinary nature of the skills which underpin them. I have one note of caution for the Government in applauding their continued commitment to education and skills. We must not take too narrow an approach to defining economically valuable skills. Breadth is important because it gives us the flexibility to adapt to circumstances we cannot or do not foresee. I am partly moved to raise this point because at the beginning of this month the Government published their blueprint for the future of higher education. Higher ambition made it clear that the Government increasingly intend to focus public expenditure on those subject groups that they believe are most likely to deliver economic benefits, such as science, technology, engineering and maths—the STEM subjects. There is a good rationale for this. Employers frequently cite these so-called stem skills as being particularly desirable and I commend particularly the joint support provided by the Government and the Wellcome Trust for the science learning centres. I had an opportunity yesterday at its reception to learn more about the excellent progress that its regional centres have made in improving the motivation of young people to do science. The director, Professor John Holman, felt that we are on the edge of a renaissance of people doing physics, but its funding is guaranteed only until 2011. I ask my noble friend to review this to see whether a commitment to extend funding of this vital work can be given, so investing in something that is already successful. Current strategies are paying off here. This country is now competing well internationally in its proportion of young science graduates. The Government may feel that patterns of study within STEM subjects need to change, which points to the need for a nuanced and evidence-based approach to growing STEM numbers. This broader approach is echoed in the recent CBI report focused on STEM provision, whose recommendations urge that STEM teaching should be better funded; all young people should continue in some form of maths education post-16; and all students with the capacity to take triple science at GCSE should be encouraged to do so. I also want to reinforce the points made in all our previous skills debates about the vital importance of a vibrant further education sector. It will be the engine enabling economic recovery. Colleges can energise young people with the flexibility of their offering, and focused support and guidance. Colleges can partner schools and academies, work with employers, and join universities and community leaders to raise the aspirations of young people. It is worth recalling that over half of foundation degrees are delivered in colleges. The higher education framework and the skills strategy are both essential to equipping this country to meet the demands of a knowledge economy. The Government are absolutely right in their unswerving commitment to ensure that the UK education system is world class, and that it equips individuals not only to make the most of their capabilities, but sets them up for satisfying, rewarding careers that contribute to our national strength. But I do not believe that education is simply about equipping individuals for jobs—and I do not think employers believe that either. I look forward to hearing how the Children, Schools and Families Bill will take forward the aspiration to shape the curriculum with the knowledge and skills that future employers need. But I shall look to be reassured that, particularly at primary level, this will not overshadow the more important task of stimulating the capacity and desire to participate in broadly based education.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
715 c556-9 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Related items
Deposited Paper DEP2009-3025
Thursday, 26 November 2009
Deposited papers
House of Lords
Subjects
Children Curriculum Age Equality Health services Fees and charges Equal pay Discrimination Home care services Home education NHS Recruitment Poverty Primary education Personal, social, health and economic education Schools
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk