Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Murphy of Torfaen (Labour) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 3 November 2011. It occurred during Debate on Commission on Devolution in Wales.


Commission on Devolution in Wales

But constituencies have nothing to do with better democracy and everything to do with partisanship. The Government were so stubborn in refusing 10% flexibility in the other place that taking local government boundaries into account is hardly possible because of the rigidity that has been introduced in the system. If there had been consensus, that might have been considered, but there was no such consensus. Finally, we have to be careful that the proposals are not based on a hidden agenda from the Government—what I call the Trojan horse. The hon. Member for Monmouth referred to the West Lothian question, and the Silk commission's hiving off financial responsibility to the Welsh Assembly, and perhaps taking away the block grant—we do not know for sure—is part of the agenda of the new Conservative party. It used to be the Conservative and Unionist party, but it has long since ceased to be Unionist. The West Lothian question means that the Government want to have two classes of Members of Parliament, not British-United Kingdom Members of Parliament who speak on everything because we have been elected by our electors to talk about the United Kingdom—every part of it: Northern Ireland, Scotland, Wales and England. I referred to the complaints time and again that we are getting too much money in Wales and Scotland. Perhaps the most obvious thing is that out of 117 Members of Parliament representing constituencies in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland, only nine come from the Conservative party. It will probably be wiped out at the next general election in Scotland and who knows where else. The combination of all those things, to me, means that the Conservative party has now become a party of little England. I am sure the hon. Member for Monmouth, who represents a Welsh constituency, would agree.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
534 c1155 
Session
2010-12
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Accountability Devolution Cross border cooperation Public consultation National Assembly for Wales Public expenditure Wales Taxation Commission on Devolution in Wales
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk