Skip to main content

Written question asked by Baroness Maclean of Redditch (Conservative) on Monday, 15 June 2026, in the House of Lords. It was due for an answer on Monday, 29 June 2026. It was answered by Lord Timpson (Labour) on Monday, 22 June 2026 on behalf of the Ministry of Justice.


Ian Paterson

Question

To ask His Majesty's Government what assessment they have made of reports of the failure to notify victims of Ian Paterson over the proposed transfer to Category D (open) prison conditions in 2024; what remedial action has been taken; and what changes to internal processes at the Ministry of Justice have been introduced to prevent a recurrence.

Answer

The Security Categorisation Policy Framework requires that, when assessing a prisoner’s suitability for transfer to open conditions, which is a categorisation review, prisons must establish whether any victims are engaged with the Victim Contact Scheme and take account of any relevant victim-related considerations. Where a victim is engaged in the Scheme, their allocated Victim Liaison Officer will notify them that a re-categorisation review is taking place and seek any information they wish to provide regarding potential risks. Victims are also given the opportunity to submit representations on additional licence conditions, such as, exclusion zones or non-contact conditions. The policy is clear that a check must be undertaken on every occasion that re-categorisation is considered, as victims may choose to join the Victim Contact Scheme at any stage during an offender’s sentence.

In this case, due to a legal challenge by the offender, the prison in which he was held was required to make a fresh decision regarding his suitability for open conditions. While this process affected the usual timeframe for engagement with Victim Liaison Unit staff, the prison confirmed that a transfer to open conditions would not be progressed without input from the Victim Liaison Unit. The prison subsequently liaised with the allocated Victim Liaison Officers, and Mr Paterson did not transfer to an open prison because the re-categorisation decision to Category D was ultimately rescinded.

The Security Categorisation Policy Framework was last updated and published in April 2025; in this update, the process for allowing victim input into categorisation assessments for open conditions was strengthened, including the introduction of a minimum 14-day notification period, to allow Victim Liaison Officers sufficient time to consult victims. Alongside this update, the HMPPS Victims Team has issued communications to Victim Liaison Officers reinforcing the process for open conditions, including guidance on when victims should be notified and the information that may be shared with them.


Secondary information

Type
Written question
Reference
HL965
Session
2026-27
Subjects
Prisoners' transfers Victims Open prisons Paterson, Ian
Link
View this Written question on www.parliament.uk