Skip to main content

Oral question asked in the House of Commons, by Oliver Heald (Conservative). It was answered on Tuesday, 28 March 2006 on behalf of the Department for Constitutional Affairs.


Power Commission

Question
I welcome the hon. Lady to her enhanced responsibilities. She will be aware that the Power commission recommended a substantially elected second Chamber, and the Lord Chancellor has begun discussions in the hope of bringing that about. Does she not agree with the commission that the main purpose of doing so is to try to establish a second Chamber that has greater legitimacy in holding the Government to account? If so, how does she reconcile that with the Labour manifesto commitment to legislate to weaken the ability of the House of Lords to scrutinise the legislation, as the two do not add up?
Answer

I do not agree that the two do not add up. When we look at reform it is important that we decide what the relevant processes are and what the House of Lords should do. Most Members of Parliament agree that that is how we should proceed before we decide the composition. I hope that in discussions now and in the near future we can come as close as possible to consensus. There is a wide variety of opinion in the House, as was clear the last time that the issue was debated, when not one of eight options was finally agreed. There is therefore much to discuss and I am sure that we all look forward to doing so.


Secondary information

Type
Oral question
Reference
444 c671 
Session
2005-06
Oral question type
Supplementary
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Democracy Elections Political parties Political activities Politics and government Public participation Voting behaviour Young people Politics Power Commission
Link
View this Oral question on www.publications.parliament.uk