Proceeding contribution from Lord Giddens (Labour) in the House of Lords on Friday, 14 October 2005. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on Internal Market in Services (EUC Report).
Internal Market in Services (EUC Report)
My Lords, I normally do not like to agree with what everyone else is saying, but in this case I have to. I congratulate the members of the committee on their excellent report, which is incisive, rigorous and well argued. Noble Lords would expect me to say that because I agree with almost everything in the report. I should like to single out a number of points and elaborate on them. First, the creation of an effective, competitive market in services is crucial for the future of Europe’s economies. It is also crucial for the now stalled Lisbon process. Looking at the occupational statistics for Europe and the other industrial countries, the changes that have taken place over the past 20 years are truly amazing. The proportion of the workforce in the EU fifteen working in manufacturing today is only 15 per cent. According to the latest statistics for this country, it is only 12 per cent, while extraordinarily in the United States, the proportion is now down to 10 per cent. Moreover, those proportions will almost certainly fall further. This means that all net new jobs have to be created in the diversity of service industries. It also means that we must make these industries competitive. A recent OECD report already referred to looks at the future of the industrial societies in general and includes information on the EU countries. It makes the point that every industrial country must become much more competitive in the area of services. One way to do this that is stressed by the OECD—but not so much in the report—is by the introduction of far greater penetration of ICT into certain kinds of service delivery. Secondly, the report is completely correct to stress the urgency of this issue. On page 45 it states that the EU must be ““bold””. The EU is not always known for its boldness and that must include the European Commission, which actually has been bold on this issue. It also has to include the national leaders of Europe who, if I may say so, have been far less bold in promoting it. I am sure that all noble Lords will have read the report of the group chaired by Andre Sapir on the economic future of Europe. The report and Andre Sapir’s subsequent writings argue cogently that completion of the single market is the most important factor that can lever better performance in the European economies. To this we have to add the issue of outsourcing, a matter not discussed in detail in the report. But whatever happens with the notorious services directive, international outsourcing will advance. Even the most conservative reports on international outsourcing take that view. It goes far beyond call centres; it can and will affect financial, legal and medical services. For example, hospitals in the United States already send X-rays to India for interpretation overnight or over the weekend. The doctor can then make a diagnosis either the next day or on the Monday, having been off work. Similarly, even the most conservative study on the future of outsourcing, one produced by McKinsey, argues that 4 per cent of all jobs in the EU fifteen will be lost by 2012. This means that Europe must gear up for more efficiency in the vast area of services, an area which now constitutes essentially what our economy is all about. Thirdly, the report is quite right on the principle of the country of origin, which is really the most notorious part of the services directive. The country of origin principle covers the temporary element. Progress has been made because all these issues have been discussed intensively over the past two years; that is, before this report was produced. Of course we have to define clearly what ““temporary”” means in this situation, but as other speakers have said, the country of origin principle will not produce a race to the bottom. Looked at what happened after the first debate on the expansion of globalisation. Many thought that that would produce a race to the bottom in European countries because we are not just competing internally, we are competing with countries which have far lower wage rates. Did it produce a race to the bottom? No, it did not. It produced net benefits both for poorer societies and for the industrial countries. The same can be expected to happen in the EU. I invite noble Lords to look at recent studies of the impact of eastern Europe and the famous Polish plumber. It shows that much of what was said about that, and which was then believed by the citizenry, was simply false. It is worth bearing in mind a study by Katinka Barysch of the Centre for European Reform. Her report shows that what are now called the central European countries, those which used to be referred to as the ““eastern European countries””, have been integrated with the EU fifteen for about 15 years, since the fall of the Berlin Wall. Over that time all these economies have enjoyed a net benefit. For example, in the EU economies over the 1990s there was a net benefit of something like 115,000 jobs, not job losses, because of economic integration. So fears of a race to the bottom are certainly, in my view, misplaced. The fourth issue is the issue of public services, which is very important. Many of the people who have been in favour of the services directive have felt uneasy about this; for example, in areas such as medical services, as has been mentioned. On the other hand, however, as the report states, the European Commission has done much to meet these objections—each country can define what counts as its public services—and so it is quite right for the report to argue that maybe it has gone slightly too far because, where public services are provided by outsourced financial competition, they surely should be subject to the same regulation as other service industries. All this having been said, we should ask why the services directive has produced such an emotional response across Europe. ““Services directive””—what a banal European-style term. Why should it provoke so much passion across Europe? You would not know from the slightly dry-as-dust report that it has provoked so much passion. But it has, and it continues to do so. I downloaded yesterday something off the Internet in which someone described it as the ““services directive from hell””, the worst thing that has been visited on the European Union over recent years. Why should this be? There is a reason. It is very important to understand the backdrop and I feel that the report lacks an attempt to tease out the implications. The backdrop is essentially the structural development of the EU over the past few years, driven by the Commission, in two areas—first, the single currency, and, secondly, the single market. These are areas over which the European Commission has a great deal of ““competence””, to put it in Euro jargon. But the welfare systems—the systems of social protection—have not been driven forward. These issues are not covered within the remit of the EC and the Commission itself does not have much power in this area. So many of the criticisms come from the supposition that what is happening in Europe—because of the position of the single currency and the single market—is essentially a marketisation of European society. That is why people are so worried about the European social model. The report contains about half a page on the European social model—it should have more—and it states, seemingly based on an odd remark by the Minister for Europe, that the European social model is so vague a notion that there is not much point in using it. This is completely false. The European social model is a shorthand term for the advanced systems of welfare which the most developed countries in Europe have established and which provide for not only a market-based society but a society which offers social protection for its citizens; which protects them against a large number of risks, including health risks; and which centrally tries to reduce the inequalities that a purely market-driven society would have. We saw what happened—if the Benches opposite will forgive me—during the Thatcherite period where market-driven policies produced a radical increase in economic inequalities. The European social model must be defended. But how can it be defended by people who, like me, support the services directive? This is one of the central questions for Europe. In conclusion, although some people say the services directive is undercutting the European model, I would argue forcefully the opposite. You cannot defend and preserve the European social model if you do not introduce these provisions. To show why, look at the best performing countries in Europe. They include, to some extent, the United Kingdom, but primarily they are the Scandinavian countries—Denmark, Sweden and Finland—together with Ireland and one or two others. What have these countries done? They have opened themselves out to the market. But have they undercut social protection? No. These have been the most reformist countries in Europe, especially the Scandinavian countries. We want a society in Europe which combines competitiveness in the global economy with social protection. We know it can be done—and that is the kind of model we should push for.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 674 c505-8
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Conditions of employment Consumers Health services Health and safety EU internal trade EU action Protection Standards Small businesses Regulation Service industries
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-21 14:06:27 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_266818
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_266818
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_266818