Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Ramsbotham (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 20 October 2005. It occurred during Parliamentary proceeding on Prisons: Suicides.


Prisons: Suicides

My Lords, I begin by joining those who have congratulated the noble Lord, Lord Dholakia, on initiating the debate, and I salute him for the breadth and wisdom of his initial contribution. I come to this subject with no great pleasure, particularly as in my time as the Chief Inspector of Prisons the subject of overcrowding came up over and over again, as did unfortunately the rising number of suicides. What concerned me about overcrowding was not just the number of people who were held in cells that were not designed to hold more than one, but the effects on the whole prison system, in that overcrowded prisons meant overstretched staff and that the resources that were needed to help people to come out and not reoffend were so choked that people were denied anything to do. So the overcrowding is to my mind just as important in terms of its effect on the regimes and therefore on the protection of the public by preventing reoffending than merely the number of people in cells. I have two quotations from other people. Once, when inspecting a young offender institution in Warwickshire I had the great pleasure of finding one of my ex-corporals who had been with me in Belfast, who was the receiver for juveniles coming into custody. I asked him, ““If I could wave a magic wand, what would you for?”” He said, ““Time. We are run off our feet, and we do not have time to give to these young people. Twenty minutes talking to some of these young lads as a responsible adult male is probably more important than anything that is going to happen to them””. I should like to draw attention to the word ““time””. Secondly, the leader in the Guardian of Friday 14 October stated:"““There is one clear lesson from earlier prison overcrowding crises. They cannot be resolved by a building programme. That approach has been tried by both Conservative and Labour administrations with disastrous results””." It has been described like putting another lane on the M25 that merely gets filled up as soon as you have done so. The article continues:"““There were three main drivers of this process. First, prison became a political football between the two major parties. Each tried—and still does—to sound tougher than the other. Criminologists have documented how tough political rhetoric at the top feeds down to sterner sentences from the bench. Second, a succession of ever more punitive criminal justice laws ratcheted up the numbers who were put away. Third, both politicians and the judiciary were egged on by feral tabloid press campaigns””." Am I alone in being upset and concerned that the Prime Minister’s understandable wish to be tough on crime and tough on the causes of crime seems to have become distorted by an ““R”” that he has found on a carpet in Downing Street? He now appears to want to be tough on ““causers”” of crime, which is not the same thing at all. I am disappointed that last week the Prime Minister criticised the judiciary and called for anti-social behaviour orders for 10 year-olds, which wound up that feral tabloid press, which will wind up the public, which will wind up the Prime Minister and ratchet the whole thing up more. Can we please have some consistency? I applauded what the Home Secretary said to the Prison Reform Trust on the need to tackle re-offending and to deal with individuals as individuals. Yet almost immediately afterwards he suggested that the Probation Service, which of all services deals with individuals in the community, should be privatised. That would undermine the ability to deliver community sentences, which are needed as an alternative to custody. Please may we have consistency? The leader also states:"““The end result is that now we have more prisoners per head of population than some of the most repressive foreign regimes, such as Burma, China and Saudi Arabia . . . Prison only exacerbates these problems [faced by prisoners]. It breaks the three key bonds that help people go straight: one-third lose their homes, two-fifths contact with their families, two-thirds their jobs””." Often, when crises arise, people say that they do not know the facts. This week the Prison Reform Trust published a wonderful document called Bromley Briefings, to which I draw noble Lords’ attention. I suggest that they put it on their required reading list. Toby Bromley, who enabled it to happen, was a remarkable man who wished the public to know the facts. The facts are here:"““This briefing has been produced to provide clear, accurate information on the state of our prison system and the lives of men, women and children within it . . . While this briefing presents facts and figures it is not merely about numbers. It is designed to prompt a response to people held in our least visible, most neglected, public service””." I feel ashamed when I look at the briefing because it describes what is happening in our prisons—in an allegedly civilised country—which has been known about for years, yet we seem helpless to do anything about it. But are we helpless? The year 1919 is mentioned, and I could go back to 1776 and the state of our prisons, but I shall refer to two documents. One was published by the noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf, following the riots in Strangeways. He says:"““On the evidence, prison riots cannot be dismissed as one off events, or as local disasters or as a run of bad luck. They are symptomatic of serious underlying difficulties in the prison system. They will only be brought to an end if those difficulties are addressed””." As a practical soldier I know that dealing with people requires things with people involved, looking after people. What worries me about current government initiatives, such as the National Offender Management Service—I wish that it were called the National Offender Management System, as that it is really what it is all about—is that they seem to treat people as commodities, which they are not. The service deals not so much with the management of offenders but with the management of the management of offenders. The only White Paper ever published on prisons, Custody, Care and Justice, in September 1991, following the Woolf report, said:"““The White Paper recognises, as the Woolf Report recognised, that a better and more stable prison system requires a coherent and consistent strategy for the Prison Service. This White Paper provides such a strategy””." It lists 12 priorities, of which three are:"““To provide active and relevant programmes for all prisoners, including unconvicted prisoners. To end overcrowding. To develop community prisons which will involve the gradual realignment of the prison estate into geographically coherent groups serving most prisoners within their area””." If only that strategy had been followed, which it has not, we might still be having this debate today, but I suspect that we would not be faced with these dreadful figures. If the Government wish to do something about this, I beg them to stop imposing on the time of people who are trying to deal with prisoners and having to sort out systems and bureaucracy. All that NOMS has achieved so far is two additional layers of bureaucracy, effectively cutting the budgets of the Prison Service and the Youth Justice Board by requiring money for it, and demolishing and demoralising the probation service. I am very distressed to have to stand here and say that.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
674 c899-902 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Abuse Alcoholic drinks Asylum Detainees Counselling Women Immigration Domestic abuse Drugs Mental illness Prisoners Prisons Misuse Life imprisonment Mental health services Prisoners on remand Overcrowding Sentencing Young offenders Suicide Prison accommodation
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk