Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Gordon Prentice (Labour) in the House of Commons on Friday, 21 October 2005. It occurred during Debate on bill on Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill.


Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill

I promise not to take long, but I want to put on the record my thanks to the Member for Birmingham, Ladywood (Clare Short) for bringing forward this Bill, which is long overdue. I want to pick up where the Member for Somerton and Frome (Mr. Heath) left off: who wants the Bill? The former Leader of the Opposition, the Member for Richmond, Yorks (Mr. Hague), wants it. Lord Hurd, the former Conservative Foreign Secretary, wants it. Our friend and former colleague, the late Robin Cook, wants it. The Foreign Secretary, I suspect, wants it, because my friend from Ladywood quoted his remarks from way back in 1994. He said that the"““royal prerogative has no place in a modern western democracy””" and that it"““has been used as a smoke-screen by Ministers to obfuscate the use of power for which they are insufficiently accountable””." To his credit, he argued for a vote in this place before the Government took the nation to war. Who else is for the Bill and the principles behind it? The Member for Kirkcaldy and Cowdenbeath (Mr. Brown), who could become the next Prime Minister, is in favour. So who is against? The Prime Minister is against the Bill. Iraq is like a ball and chain round his ankle, and he cannot bear the thought of prime ministerial powers being fettered in this way, but it will happen. I want to put the Government’s position on the record. We discussed the issue of the royal prerogative in the Public Administration Committee in 2004, producing a good, considered report and spending a long time on it. It bears reading and re-reading. The Government responded to our report, which recommended that parliamentary approval should be sought, if possible, in advance of armed conflict, but if that were not possible, as soon afterwards as may be, by saying this:"““The Government’s view is that the pragmatic approach, allowing the circumstances of Parliamentary scrutiny to reflect the circumstances of the armed conflict, continues to be the more effective approach.””" That is just pathetic. It is the Member for Sedgefield (Mr. Blair) who believes this, not many others on the Labour Benches. Why is this Bill needed? I will tell the House why. Because of the chaotic system of decision making in the run-up to the war. If parliamentary approval had been necessary, members of the Cabinet would have got involved, rather than acting as a kind of stage army—wheeled into No. 10, given a few PowerPoint presentations and being told by the Prime Minister, no doubt, ““If you knew what I know; if you could see what comes across my desk.”” All that kind of stuff. If members of the Cabinet had insisted that the papers that had been prepared by the civil service be circulated in advance, that would have made a difference. Instead—I do not want to be offensive—it was like turnips round the table, with no one asking the simple, obvious questions. I think we still have a Minister without Portfolio. Have we? Well, the Minister without Portfolio should be charged with the task of asking simple and obvious questions in Cabinet. We need that. My friend from Ladywood famously told the Cabinet Secretary, Sir Andrew Turnbull, that he allowed the decision-making structures to crumble on his watch. I am not going to rerun the history of Iraq, but this is relevant: she went on to say that the Cabinet Sub-Committee that deals with defence and foreign policy did not meet in the run-up to the war. Now, we had Sir Andrew Turnbull in front of the Select Committee and I put that to him. I said, ““Clare Short alleges that the defence and foreign policy Committee did not meet in the run-up to the war in Iraq. Is that true?”” He said, ““No, not really.”” He was very economical with the truth. He went on to say, ““But the Cabinet discussed it on 24 occasions.”” Of course they did not discuss it; there were no papers circulated. It was the Prime Minister just giving a little update on what he thought was relevant. So, that is why we need the Bill. I have no confidence at all in the Cabinet being fully engaged if there was a problem in Iran, for example. Of course, there are some things about this that I still find absolutely incredible. The Prime Minister was famously ignorant of whether the weapons of mass destruction were strategic or battlefield. That is absolutely, literally incredible.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
437 c1097-9 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Accountability Armed forces Armed conflict Deployment Democracy Prime Minister Parliamentary scrutiny Treaties Royal prerogative
Legislation
Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk