Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Andrew Dismore (Labour) in the House of Commons on Friday, 21 October 2005. It occurred during Debate on bill on Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill.


Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill

That presages my arguments under clause 8. I am not sure that that was necessarily the case. As I recall, one of the arguments in relation to Srebrenica concerned the rules of engagement under which the UN was operating at the time. Part of the problem was that they were restrictive and ambiguous, and, facing that, the Dutch troops did not feel willing to commit themselves. As my right hon. Friend’s requirement under clause 8 is that action must be either ““following a lawful command”” or"““in accordance with lawful rules of engagement””," those troops are left in an ambiguous position. They do not have time to phone up the Prime Minister to ask him to apply retrospectively for a motion in Parliament, or to wait for a vote in Parliament to decide whether they are allowed to shoot back. I shall return to those arguments later. I presaged my concerns about clause 2 when I intervened on the question of judicial intervention. It is not a question of the courts overruling Parliament, but of the courts interpreting and ruling on whether the Government’s interpretation of what Parliament has decided is lawful and reasonable. Let me give an example. One of the matters that the Government must lay before Parliament is the expected duration of the participation in armed conflict. Let us suppose that the Government say that the war will be over by Christmas—it has been known before—and that the war is still going on at Easter. There is nothing to stop somebody going to the courts to seek judicial review, saying, ““The Government are continuing a war without lawful authority, because Parliament debated it on the general understanding that the war would be over by Christmas. It hasn’t happened that way. Please, judge, give me an injunction to require the Government to withdraw their troops.””


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
437 c1146-7 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Accountability Armed forces Armed conflict Deployment Democracy Prime Minister Parliamentary scrutiny Treaties Royal prerogative
Legislation
Armed Forces (Parliamentary Approval for Participation in Armed Conflict) Bill 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk