---

Health Bill

May I push the hon. Gentleman in a different direction on loopholes and private members’ clubs? A private members’ club such as the Garrick in London is a very different beast from a private members’ club such as Treorchy working men’s social club, because the working men’s clubs in constituencies such as mine are, to all intents and purposes, the place that people normally go to do their drinking, as if it were an ordinary pub. If we exempt working men’s clubs, we will do nothing for the vast majority of the poorest people in my constituency who are equally affected.