Proceeding contribution from Lord Rooker (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 2 March 2006. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Budget (Northern Ireland) Order 2006.
Budget (Northern Ireland) Order 2006
Somewhere in my notes it says that we have had an ““interesting debate””. I do not think that I need to refer to my notes for that; we have had an interesting debate. I will do my best, in my self-limited time, to respond to some of the points. I am afraid that I will have to write letters on those I do not respond to. I have got some really interesting answers here, but they are probably an hour’s work and I do not intend to spend an hour on my feet. It is as simple as that. A couple of preliminary points will set the scene, so that there is no misunderstanding. I think that the penny has dropped. Nobody is being blackmailed or threatened. The Secretary of State has made the position clear since he took office last year: we will proceed with a programme of reform. Our experience in Wales, Scotland and England over the past few years has shown us that a reform programme can benefit our citizens. Northern Ireland has been missed out of that programme, and we are going to ensure that its people share in it. We intend to speed up the process of reform. There will be more decisions on the 21st of this month regarding quangos. We will implement those and get the legal process under way in this House before the summer with regard to local government. The Boundary Commission order for local government boundaries, which will have legal authority, will contain the number of councils and other information. That process is under way, and, if we can, we will speed it up. I am dealing with one of the questions asked by the noble Lord, Lord Glentoran. The order is imminent; hopefully, it will be published this month and go through both Houses by the summer, which I take to be June. The advertising for the appointment of the Boundary Commissioner will follow shortly after that. It takes about a year to do the work, so we are talking about the summer of 2007 before we get a report from the commissioner. By the end of this year, though, following the announcement on the quangos on the 21st, we will have done sufficient preparatory work for the legality of handing over the substantial extra powers to local government. The powers will require other orders to go through the Westminster Parliament. The new councils are planned for May 2009. Although it is too early to say, our preference would be to have them elected in 2008 and spend a year in shadow. If that cannot be done and it has to be 2009, we would probably think about extending the life of the existing councils. There needs to be an overlap. We cannot have a cliff-edge here, with the old councils out and the new ones in with new powers. There will have to be preparatory work, such as the appointment of chief executives. In the mean time, the reforms of health and education, which do not require any parliamentary changes, will proceed. By 2007–08 the various blocks that we announced in November for the changes will be implemented. The Public Services Commission will be set up on a non-statutory basis, because there is no time to do it statutorily, and the Government are committed to following its recommendations, using our best endeavours to implement them. If we cannot do so, we will give a full factual public explanation of why we are not prepared to accept a recommendation, but that will be very much the exception rather than the rule. That is proceeding. It is not done as a threat, or for blackmail. The fact is that it will benefit our fellow citizens in Northern Ireland. It would be much better if the Assembly were doing this, or operating as the Assembly in other ways, but we are not there to mind the shop. We will proceed faster. The Secretary of State has made clear, as is indicated in the legislation published last week and introduced in the other place, which we will get during the summer, that there will be provision for an all-Ireland market in electricity. Where we can have good cross-border co-operation to the advantage of both sides, we must do so, and we will speed it up and make it deeper. That is our position. It is not an ideological argument; there are good, practical reasons for it. I will do my best to answer some of the more detailed points. With regard to the EU directives on the environment—on drinking water, waste water and fresh water—there is a cost involved, but they will significantly improve the quality of life for people and the natural environment in Northern Ireland. There is a whole range of capital projects that need to be implemented as soon as possible. I will try to deal with the points in the order that they were asked because that is much easier, even though there will be some duplication. Regarding the strategic review of education provision, there has to be an efficient use of education funding. Preparatory work is going ahead now, as of January this year, for the Comprehensive Spending Review, which will start next year and be fairly substantial. A root and branch review of education spending will be undertaken to ensure that the Government’s massive year-on-year increase is delivering the outcome that we need and that parents expect on the ground. Necessary action will be taken on the schools estate to ensure the efficient and effective use of all available resources. The review of the schools estate is in response to changing pupil numbers, which the noble Lord, Lord Shutt, mentioned. There are changing patterns, which may—indeed, dare I say, will—lead to some school closures. In some cases it may be possible to put two schools in one building. Children can play and work together. The ethos of separate schools can still be maintained, but it is highly practical to do that. I am not saying that would be the case in all situations, but in some areas there are tiny schools quite close to each other. The ethos of both needs to be preserved, but the children’s education will suffer if the schools are allowed to be too small. On public sector employment, yes, it forms too great a part of the economy. That stifles Northern Ireland’s economy and we have no chance of getting it anywhere near that of the Republic with the present balance of the public and private sectors. That is not to say that we want to squash the public sector. We will have to drive up the private sector. We do not have a programme of privatisation as such, but where things can be better done by the private sector, they should be. At present, the employment level is 33 per cent. There is a reform programme in place to reduce that. It is known in the Civil Service that there is a plan for 2,300 jobs to be shed, some 48 per cent of which have already gone. We have already delivered that. On Translink, I regret to say that I have not used the train in Northern Ireland. There are certain things I cannot do; I am simply not free to pop out and wander around. Put it this way: I get advice and I follow it. I am not there to cause problems for people. Translink has not approached the department of finance with a business case for any proposed development at city airport. If it does, we will consider that in the context of its development. I think that the noble Lord, Lord Shutt, was talking about the terminal. The runway is staying. I can see the old terminal as I fly in and out twice a week. Looking at the state of it, I am glad I did not have to use it. I do not have any plans for the railway, but all the points that have been made in this debate will be sent to relevant departments, make no mistake about that. On Ulster Savings, the issue of dormant funds—this is an escape clause I am going to use on many issues—is a matter that is reserved and for the Treasury. Basically, if it is not for the Northern Ireland Assembly, it is not for this Committee. By Orders in Council, we are doing only what is within the competence of the Assembly. If it is reserved, it is for the Treasury. It is true that it would be a Westminster job, but our rules in the Lords are different on money in any case. The issue of victims’ expenditure programmes was raised. Expenditure has not reached the levels anticipated during this phase. That is part of the reason why the money has been shifted around. The appointment of the recently appointed interim Commissioner for Victims and Survivors in the coming financial year will probably speed up that process, so it is not a question of money being lost, or cuts. The fact is that it did not proceed as fast as planned. Regarding the token vote for the Civic Forum, the £1,000 was a figure put in to make sure it does not get closed down. That was one thing that I knew before. The minute the Assembly is back, that can speed up. The funds can be allocated quite quickly, so there should be no difficulty about that.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 679 c237-40GC
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords Grand Committee
- Subjects
- Compensation Crime Airports Employment Education Electricity Infrastructure Local government Northern Ireland Public sector Public expenditure Non-departmental public bodies Schools Reform Victims Sportsgrounds Per capita costs Translink
- Legislation
- Budget (Northern Ireland) Order 2006
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-22 02:12:22 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_304642
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_304642
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_304642