Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 7 March 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Company Law Reform Bill [HL].


Company Law Reform Bill [HL]

moved Amendment No. 315ZAI:"Page 194, line 15, leave out second ““accountant’s”” and insert ““independent examiner’s””" The noble Lord said: At the same time, I shall speak to a large group of amendments—Amendments Nos. 315ZAW, 315CA to 315CC, and 315DA to 315DE—and address the Questions whether Clauses 464 to 466 should stand part of the Bill. Also, at the back of the Bill, I shall speak to Amendments Nos. A211 and A223. This group of amendments has been raised with us by the Association of Charity Independent Examiners, which is an umbrella body, a recognised professional body with proper training leading to a fellowship. It focuses on the specific needs of the financial reporting of charities. I first encountered it during the passage of the Charities Bill through your Lordships’ House. This group of amendments would remove an anomaly in the present regulatory structure. I fear that it will take me a minute or two to explain and I beg the forbearance of the Committee, but I am dealing with 19 amendments at one hit, so there is some bang for the buck, so to speak. First, I turn to the methodology for the financial regulation of charities. Charities can be based on a trust or a corporate structure, and the vast majority of charities not based on a company are based on a trust. Those charities are subject to four layers of financial supervision, beginning with the largest, where accounts are required to be audited. In those circumstances it is where the gross income exceeds £500,000, or alternatively the gross income exceeds £100,000 per annum and the aggregate value of the assets of the charity exceeds £2.8 million. That deals with charities that are rich in assets but have a relatively low income. Below that there is the possibility of independent examination instead of an audit, and that is for charities whose gross income exceeds £250,000. Below that, there is independent examination where the gross income exceeds £10,000 per annum, and finally where charities are smaller than that no examination is required. Not all charities are based on trusts; some are based on a corporate structure and are companies. The current legal position as regards accounting and auditing for small companies does not fit that now being offered to charitable companies. This large group of amendments forms an attempt to regularise the situation. The amendments apply only to smaller companies which are charities and are concerned with the scrutiny of the accounts of a charitable company where its income is below the audit threshold. As I said, at present, charitable companies with an income of between £90,000 and £250,000 are required to have a report drawn up by a reporting accountant. However, this regime was never designed specifically with charities in mind and lasted for only a short time in relation to small companies in general. Its continued application in this Bill to charitable companies is quite anomalous. In the meantime, we have had pretty widespread experience of the regime for independent examination of accounts of charities which are not companies—the regime I have just described—under which the examiner considers the reports on many issues which are likely to be of relevance to users of charity accounts. By their very nature they are different from those of normal companies and are completely overlooked by the reporting account regime designed for companies. I should like to ask the Minister and the Bill team to look at the discussions held in Grand Committee on the Charities Bill on 14 March 2005. We discussed with the Minister’s colleague, the noble Lord, Lord Bassam of Brighton, the position of the Association of Independent Charity Examiners. The noble Lord said:"““I agree to consider whether we ought to put it on the list of eligible bodies. The noble Lord has made a good point and we will consider it””.—[Official Report, 14/3/05; col. GC 461.]" Indeed, the Government then brought it into the Charities Bill, the draft of which is now in the other place. This is an important development and I mention it this afternoon because it shows that the AICE is a body which has been checked out and verified by the Minister’s colleagues in the Home Office. The amendments take account of the slightly different independent examination regime which applies in England and Wales on the one hand, and Scotland on the other. That is because Scotland operates under different charity law. They follow the Bill’s current approach of treating charitable companies in Northern Ireland on the same basis as those in England and Wales. That is because charity law in Northern Ireland is currently the same as that in England and Wales. By referring to existing provisions in charity law on the appointment, independence, professional qualifications and reporting duties of independent examiners, the amendments we have tabled considerably reduce the provisions needed in the Bill—and I know that the noble Lord, Lord Sainsbury, and I agree about the deregulatory aspects. I am offering him some deregulation on a plate. The accounts of charities are normally subject to the charities SORP—the statement of recommended practice—whether or not the charity is a company. These amendments also mean that the rules on independent scrutiny will be brought into line with that SORP. Having explained the background, at this point I shall go quickly through the amendments individually. First, Amendment No. 315ZAI, which is the trigger for this group in Clause 422 on the filing obligations of companies subject to the small companies regime, inserts ““independent examiner’s””. Amendment No. 315CC amends Clause 454(3), which is concerned with small companies exempt from audit, and the total exemption limit below which no independent scrutiny of the accounts is required. Currently that figure is £90,000 in annual income, which most people in the charity sector feel is far too high, given that charities that are not companies are subject to independent examination once their income exceeds £10,000 per annum. The amendment aligns the lower limit with the relevant figures under charity law, likely to be £10,000 in all UK jurisdictions. Before the Minister says that we do not have a charities Act but have only a Charities Bill, I should say that the amendment refers to the existing Charities Act 1993, so we do not have to deal with what may happen to the Charities Bill in its further progress. We then have changes to Clause 459, which is on reports from small charities’ accountants in lieu of audit. Those are Amendments Nos. 315DA, 315DB and 315DC. They are concerned with the thresholds for the reporting accountant’s report which are amended to independent examination thresholds. That is set out in Amendment No. 315DB. In the case of the charity income threshold, the limit is worded to cross-refer to the Charities Act 1993; it is currently £50,000 but will increase to £500,000 once the new Charities Bill is enacted. It refers to the 1993 Act, not to the Bill. That is in Amendment No. 315DC. In the case of the asset threshold, dealt with in Amendment No. 315DA, there is no limit at present in the Charities Act, but it will be £2.8 million if the Bill is passed. In the case of charitable companies in Scotland, the Bill is already worded to refer to Scottish charity regulations, so no amendment is needed. We then get to a series of replacements. First, Amendment No. 315DD provides a new clause in place of Clause 462, entitled, ““The accountant’s report””. The new clause is entitled, ““The independent examiner’s report””. We propose that the main clause on the duties of reporting accountants is replaced with new provisions for independent examination. By cross-referring to existing charity law, the clause has been substantially shortened. Clause 463 is replaced by Amendment No. 315DE. It removes the complicated definition of reporting accountants and simply refers to the existing definition of charity independent examiners. The wording is valid even in relation to the Charities Act, but is such that it will automatically refer to the new independent examiner definitions for charities in the £250,000 to £500,000 band if and when the Charities Bill takes effect. We do not believe that Clause 464 should stand part of the Bill. It is concerned with the appointment of partnerships of reporting accountants. Since the independent examiner must be an individual, the clause is redundant. Clause 465 is concerned with the independent reporting accountants, but if the amendment to Clause 463 is accepted independent examiners of charitable companies will have to meet the independent requirements of charity law, so that clause would become redundant. Finally, Clause 466 defines ““associate”” for the purpose of Clause 465, and so would likewise be removed.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
679 c277-80GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Disclosure of information Charities Audit Accountancy Company law Company accounts Companies Directors Annual reports Finance Exemptions Internet Public companies Meetings Small businesses Timetables
Legislation
Company Law Reform Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk