Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Adam Ingram (Labour) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 29 March 2006. It occurred during Ministerial statement on Deepcut Review.


Deepcut Review

I take that point, but one of the key issues was the demand for a public inquiry. The Defence Committee said that it would wait for the Blake review, but did not consider that a public inquiry was justified, given the known circumstances. I have given more than once the reasons why I do not support a public inquiry. Mr. Blake’s review weighs all the legal considerations and all the aspects, and comes to the same conclusion. Mr. Blake says that the Army and Ministers have to make a judgment about whether more information would lay the issue to rest. My judgment is that a public inquiry would prolong the matter, and would not lead to a different conclusion. That is Mr. Blake’s conclusion, and I am more than satisfied that he has looked at all the available evidence. We cannot allow individual families to have a veto. They have been spoken to and have expressed their views, but they may never be satisfied with the decision. Their point of view will differ from the judgment that a Minister will reach. I recognise the role that the hon. Member for Montgomeryshire (Lembit Öpik) has played in this matter. Mr. Blake’s report is highly critical of the media’s sensational exploitation of the events. Stories have been run that have had no substance, with no subsequent apology for the fact that they were wrong. None the less, I accept Mr. Blake’s recognition that the pressure that the media exerts forces further ventilation and examination. I wanted this report to be completed earlier, and Mr. Blake lists the many external factors that made that impossible. In the intervening period of 15 months, substantial changes in the training environment have been introduced or are now planned. The training regime has not stood still, and it will change measurably for the better in the months and years ahead.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
444 c862-3 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Bullying Death Army Misconduct Public inquiries Training Young people Reviews Suicide Deepcut Barracks Benton, Sean Collinson, James Gray, Geoff James, Cheryl
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk