---

Health Bill

Yes, but not before we make a little progress on the points raised by the noble Lord, Lord Faulkner. He said that he has a perfect right to go to a bar and have a drink in a room that is not filled with smoke. Why can he not achieve that objective through the separation of smoking rooms from non-smoking rooms, with proper extractors installed even in the smoking room? What is wrong with that compromise? Why does he want to force people outside? That is the question that I want to ask him. It is not a philosophical question; it is a very practical question which affects the logic of the Bill.