Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Morris of Bolton (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 4 May 2006. It occurred during Committee proceeding and Debate on bill on Childcare Bill.


Childcare Bill

moved Amendment No. 57:"Page 10, leave out lines 31 to 35 and insert—" ““(1) For the purposes of this Part and Part 3, ““young children”” is the collective term for groups that contain children as outlined in subsections (2) and (3) below. (2) A child is considered a ““very young child”” during the period— (a) beginning with his birth, and (b) ending immediately before the 1st September next following the date on which he attains the age of two. (3) A child is considered a ““young child”” during the period— (a) beginning immediately on the 1st September next following the date on which he attains the age of two, and (b) ending immediately before the 1st September next following the date on which he attains the age of five.”” The noble Baroness said: I shall also speak to Amendments Nos. 59 and 70. Amendment No. 57 replaces the existing meaning of ““young children”” and breaks it into two categories: a very young child, who is aged between nought and two years old, and a young child, who is aged between two and five years old. Amendment No. 59 is a consequential amendment to that, creating two categories, ensuring that the meaning of ““early years provision”” in Clause 20 covers provision of childcare for a very young child as well as a young child. Amendment No. 70 follows that link, inserting two new paragraphs into Clause 41(3), which outlines the areas of learning and development requirements the Secretary of State must include in the early years foundation scheme. These two new paragraphs will ensure that the learning and development requirements include the vital aspects of a very young child’s sense of self and secure attachment. All the amendments highlight the significant differences in a child’s growth between what others have referred to as the ““baby”” and ““infant”” years. This builds on discussion during the passage of the Bill in the other place, and our belief that children from the age of birth to two have different needs and, as such, should be treated differently. In the other place our amendments referred to ““babies”” and ““young children””, but, after talking to experts in this field, we have amended our amendments, and our terminology now refers to ““young children”” and ““very young children””. Our primary concern to differentiate in these areas springs from our commitment to attachment theory, of which the noble Earl, Lord Listowel, spoke so convincingly earlier in Grand Committee. As my honourable friend Tim Loughton said in the other place, Conservative Members are great devotees of Sue Gerhardt’s book, Why Love Matters: How Affection Shapes A Baby’s Brain. If anyone wants it, I have a copy here. Much work is now done by organisations such as the Oxford Parent-Infant Project. I declared an interest at Second Reading, but I declare it again. I am now a patron of OXPIP, which does a lot of work with social services to provide training in attachment, as well as a lot of research. One of its main areas of that research is to show that concentrating on babies, or very young children, from birth to two can make all the difference in the development of children and their chance of leading a fulfilling adult life. On the first day of Committee, the noble Baroness, Lady Massey of Darwen, who is just walking away from her place, said that she had read some contradictory research about attachment theory, and that surely good-quality childcare is better than poor-quality homecare. No one could disagree. Poor-quality homecare is no respecter of money or education. A baby can have just as poor an attachment with a wealthy mother as with as mother from a deprived and struggling background, a mother with post-natal depression, or one who is a drug or substance abuser: all of them with their eyes blank and not available for their baby. It is vital that a baby receives consistent positive attention and care, either at home or in the nursery, but preferably in both. Good attachment means that the wiring of the baby’s brain works, and the baby is able to look at the world and say, ““This is actually a nice place””. If the baby is at a nursery, you have to look at how the baby is cared for there. Does the key worker have training in attachment theory? Do they attend to all the baby’s needs? For instance, when the baby—the young child, rather; I am slipping back into our original terminology—is handed over at the beginning of the day, does the key worker change the baby’s nappy, or do they change nappies on a rota system? When they interact with the baby, or the very young child, do they make and keep eye contact? All these things are vital for that very young child to attain the resilience that it is going to need throughout life. This is such a vast topic that I could speak for a long time, but I am mindful that we have a target to finish by today, if possible, so I will leave it at that and listen to what the Minister has to say. I beg to move.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
681 c313-5GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Staff Access Disability Disclosure of information Childcare Childminding Inspections Exemptions Grandparents Local government Qualifications Protection Parents Pre-school education Nannies Nurseries Standards Registration Teachers Training Young people Kinship care
Legislation
Childcare Bill 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk