Proceeding contribution from Lord Kingsland (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 23 January 2007. It occurred during Committee of the Whole House (HL) and Debate on bill on Legal Services Bill [HL].
Legal Services Bill [HL]
moved Amendment No. 61: 61: Clause 36, page 17, line 38, at end insert— ““( ) that the approved regulator has failed to comply with a direction made under section 31, and”” The noble Lord said: I shall speak also to Amendment No. 62. These amendments relate to the board’s power to issue financial penalties to the approved regulators. Our preferred option is to remove the power to issue financial penalties from the Bill altogether. We believe that financial penalties are inappropriate mechanisms for dealing with public interest bodies. It is usual for direct regulators of services, particularly services provided on a commercial basis, to have the power to fine those who fail to comply with regulatory requirements; but it is extremely unusual for there to be a power to fine a body that is carrying out regulatory activities on a non-commercial basis. The Council for Healthcare Regulatory Excellence has no power to fine any professional body in the medical field, nor does the Financial Reporting Council have power to fine any accountancy body. Given that the Legal Services Board has extensive power to make directions and that those directions are enforceable, it is far from clear that any power to fine approved regulators is necessary. The Joint Committee drew attention to this point in its report and the Government, as I understand it, promised to reconsider the issue. Nevertheless, the power to fine remains in the Bill. In the circumstances of legal services regulation, day-to-day responsibility for regulatory action will rest with the professional body’s regulatory arm. The representative side will not be able to control the way in which the regulatory arm operates; indeed, it would be a serious breach of the principle of independence if it were to seek to do so. But any fine would not, in reality, impact on the regulatory arm. Unless the fine were charged against the regulation side budget—which would presumably defeat the whole purpose of the fine since it would make it more difficult for the regulatory arm to put right whatever failing had led to the fine—it would, effectively, be borne by the professional body itself, and thus by its members. Members of the regulatory arm will not even be subject to any sanction from an electorate for having incurred the fine since they are all appointed under Nolan principles, rather than being elected. The consequence must be that the representative side, and hence its members, would bear the whole burden of the fine without being able to exert any effective influence over the failings that led to the fine. That simply cannot be right. If the Government are not prepared to think again about the principle, which was so well aired in the course of the proceedings of the Joint Committee, we ask them to look as an alternative at the amendments we have tabled. The purpose of Amendment No. 61, on the assumption that these financial provisions remain in the Bill, is to provide some protection for professional bodies against the situation I have described. If the Legal Services Board could fine approved regulators only after they had failed to comply with a direction, the professional body would at least be put on notice of the risk of a fine. The professional bodies could ensure that the contracts with their regulatory arms required each member to do all that he or she could to ensure that any directions from the Legal Services Board were complied with. This would substantially reduce the risk of a professional body being fined for failings it could do absolutely nothing whatever about. Amendment No. 62 is an attempt at a further safeguard by ensuring that the board would not impose financial penalties where lesser sanctions would suffice. It is designed to prevent what I would describe as a ““capricious use”” of the power to fine. There would inevitably be media pressure on regulators to flex their muscles by exercising their powers to fine at every opportunity, which is, in our view, poor regulatory practice. Good regulatory practice requires regulators to use the least heavy-handed sanction that will meet the regulatory need. Plainly it would be unacceptable to fine an approved regulator simply because the thresholds for doing so have been met. The power to fine should be properly exercised only when the Legal Services Board is satisfied that no lesser sanction would suffice. The Government have accepted this principle in relation to the board’s power to intervene in the functions of approved regulators. If the board is to have the power to fine, then there is no apparent reason why it should not also be subject to that test. I beg to move.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 688 c1023-5
- Session
- 2006-07
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Complaints Consumers Appeals Business Competition Legal profession Fees and charges Fines Powers Regulation Rural areas Legal Services Board
- Legislation
- Legal Services Bill (HL) 2006-07
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-15 11:18:31 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_372316
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_372316
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_372316