Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from John Pugh (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Commons on Tuesday, 8 May 2007. It occurred during Adjournment debate on Road Schemes.


Road Schemes

I apologise in advance for spoiling your lunch, Mr. Conway, and probably that of the Minister. It will not displease me if we do not take the full allotted time, but get straight to the point. I am glad to see the Minister here, because our careers have crossed in a very helpful way. He went from the health team in the Labour party to the transport team, whereas I passed the other way but on the Liberal Democrats’ side. He also knows my area—he has certainly visited it on a health matter and he has a personal connection with it. He also represents the seaside, so I could not ask for a better Minister on this occasion. Under the old system of developing road schemes—it was long before my time, and probably long before yours, Mr. Conway—one simply sidled up to a Minister a few years before an election and emphasised the fact that one represented a marginal constituency. Road schemes then simply happened, through the whim and desire of the Department for Transport. Fortunately, those bad days of patronage, skulduggery and political manipulation are obviously behind us. They were replaced by the epoch of the local transport plan, whereby passenger transport authorities were asked to put together schemes for road development and, sometimes, rail development in their area. The plans had a learning curve and schemes were graded as good or bad by Ministers, who scrutinised them and made announcements. LTPs were judged on an annual or sometimes triennial basis by the Government, and they were funded according to whether they reflected the policy flavour of the month or were well constructed, well argued for and seemed to deliver some of the benefits that they claimed. There were extraordinarily wide variations in the quality of work done in LTPs by passenger transport authorities. Some, as supplicants to the Department for Transport, were genuinely deeply puzzled as to why their LTP had enjoyed so little success and received so few approvals to spend. Others were only too delighted to see the good efforts in their LTPs well rewarded. In my area, Merseyside passenger transport authority did particularly well on local transport plans. In comparison, just down the road, Lancashire county council did surprisingly poorly in terms of the amount of funding that it received, yet Lancashire probably covers a wider area than Merseyside. Nowadays, we have a new system of regional prioritisation. Regional prioritisation is done by regional forums appointed by regional assemblies, yet without the essential element of regional government. I found out about the process relatively late, almost as it was occurring. As a member of the Select Committee on Transport, I was standing in for the hon. Member for Crewe and Nantwich (Mrs. Dunwoody) in a debate in this Chamber. I remember being surrounded by all sorts of experts, journalists and so on in the transport field, and breaking to them the news that regional transport schemes were being funded and were well advanced, and that they were proceeding in an almost secret, secluded fashion. Most people locked on to the schemes fairly late. They did not really recognise the process for what it was until it had more or less happened. That was the Government moving to a fairly fast time scale. In a sense, one might see the regional transport forums as a positive development. There was a predefined allocation, apparently based on a relatively fair distribution of resources, on a per-capita basis. Will the Minister confirm that? In respect of prioritisation, the process transparently has to be evidence-led. The company W.S. Atkins was employed in the north-west to score the schemes sent in by the passenger transport authorities and evaluate them on an objective and fair basis. That is how big schemes happen at the moment. The process is new and we are getting used to it, but it is one of the few games in town. Superimposed on that is what are referred to as the transport innovation funds. PTAs, or whatever body is involved, have to promise to inflict pain—a congestion charge for residents, or whatever—to reduce traffic, before securing funding for genuinely popular projects such as trams. Under the system there is, if you like, no gain without pain. I understand that the negotiations take place between the Department for Transport and various transport bodies. By and large, the transport bodies try to inflict as little pain as possible to secure as much gain as possible—““gain”” meaning funding for popular transport projects. The problem is that there is a substantial omission in the system. Good, popular, needed and affordable schemes that do not have pan-regional significance get left out of the system altogether, particularly if they cost more than £5 million, which I think is the current limit. If they cost less than that, they can be done by the local transport authority, but if they cost more they must go to regional prioritisation. I am delighted that the hon. Member for West Lancashire (Rosie Cooper) is here, because I am about to talk about schemes such as the Ormskirk bypass, which is Lancashire priority No. 2, but relatively low in the current regional prioritisation. The bypass passes all the tests that one would expect a good scheme to pass. It certainly impresses me and the hon. Lady. It impresses my constituents and hers because it offers real benefits, and it impresses West Lancashire district council, which is controlled by the Conservative party, from which neither I nor the hon. Lady come. The bypass scheme also impresses the people of Ormskirk, who have long wanted it and have thought that they might get it for almost 30 years. Hopefully, it will impress the Minister on objective criteria. There are some very good reasons for the scheme. First, it would take considerable pressure off the town of Ormskirk. Secondly, it would appreciably improve access and transport between Southport and Formby district general hospital and Ormskirk and district general hospital, which operate under the same trust; from past experience, I know that the Minister is very familiar with it. The two hospitals were merged and their services configured as a result of a report written by a Professor Shields. As I have probably told the Minister, the report had a very telling line. It said that the service configuration was supported by Professor Shields and the like, but that there were transport difficulties, which, it went on to say, were not within the remit of the health service. The health service did not need to consider those difficulties; that was for somebody else. There is an important public service aspect to the road, given that it could facilitate transport between two relatively small hospitals that are not as well linked as people in Ormskirk and Southport would wish them to be. Increasingly, people have to travel between the two clinical centres and find that problems with access are less than tolerable. There are other reasons, unconnected with health issues, for the bypass. Southport’s economy is unquestionably expanding. The Minister may have been lucky enough to catch the last edition of the programme presented by Sir Trevor McDonald, which was about coastal towns. As an example of genuine regeneration and expansion, Southport was contrasted with other coastal towns. All the research by bodies such as the Southport Partnership has identified that there are only two limits on further successful economic expansion, which would help the north-west in general: housing, which I shall not go into now, and transport links. The hon. Member for Pontypridd (Dr. Howells), in his previous capacity as the Under-Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, travelled around all the coastal towns. When he got to Southport, I asked him what his conclusion was. He said that every town that he had been to, with the possible exceptions of Bournemouth and Blackpool, wanted a better route into them. We do not simply want a better route; we have an economic case for having one. I am pleased to see the hon. Member for West Lancashire in her place; she is slightly more optimistic than I about how quickly the Minister will respond to my supplications, requests and well reasoned arguments.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
460 c54-6WH 
Session
2006-07
Chamber / Committee
Westminster Hall
Subjects
Construction Finance Roads Bypasses A59 Ormskirk
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk