Proceeding contribution from Lord Chorley (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 12 June 2007. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on Science and Heritage (Science and Technology Committee Report).
Science and Heritage (Science and Technology Committee Report)
I thank the main committee for co-opting me to the sub-committee. I hope that my background as a former chairman of the National Trust and, separately, as a former member of the NERC, was useful. I warmly welcome the outstandingly astute chairmanship of the noble Baroness, Lady Sharp. I also warmly acknowledge the skills and advice of our clerk, Dr Christopher Johnson, and our technical advisor, Dr May Cassar, in guiding us through quite complicated territory. I mention two innovations—or at least they were to me: our informal meeting with the main practitioners at Hampton Court before we started, and again after we had published our report. Both were, in their different ways, invaluable. I start with the context of our report. It was, for example, preceded by a recent House of Commons Select Committee report on the built heritage and its funding. That was pretty critical and the departmental response was pretty inadequate; that is nothing new. Quite recently, we had a major debate on the departmental raiding of the Heritage Lottery Fund of £650 million for the Olympics. There were notable and critical contributions by the noble Lords, Lord Baker of Dorking and Lord Smith of Finsbury. One also recalls a debate last December, I think led by the noble Lord, Lord Howarth, on funding of church repairs. Again, the noble Lord has outstanding knowledge and was deeply critical. His contribution this afternoon was also outstandingly thoughtful and knowledgeable. In November, the chairman of the Historic Houses Association spoke of the deteriorating funding of historic house repair grants. In that connection, the point was made that, according to the National Trust, the cost of heritage repairs is going up far faster than the Government’s indices of general inflation. There is an increasing price/funding gap, a common theme of all these reports from highly knowledgeable and responsible people or bodies. Another example: the DCMS recently underwent a capability review which made 31 references to the Olympics and not a single one to the heritage. That accurately reflects the heritage’s status in the department. Our own report, in the much narrower and specialised field of conservation science, is equally critical. Much of our criticism is on the levels of funding. There is a wider sense of a lack of departmental interest and hence ignorance in the heritage sector, and it has come out very clearly this afternoon in some of the speeches. For example, I found the evidence session with DCMS officials deeply depressing. It is difficult to put one’s finger on what exactly was wrong; there was certainly little rapport; but it was almost as if the words ““culture”” and ““heritage”” were just not part of their vocabulary. I shall restrict myself to one further example—the oral evidence of the Minister, who incidentally was in other respects rather more enthusiastic. We asked him whether there was a risk that the promotion of public access might put conservation at risk—a point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Platt. His reply was rather dismissive. We said that he, "““did not appear to acknowledge that the right to access goes beyond the present generation””." Those were the actual words that we used. We said: "““It is therefore a matter of grave concern to us that the Department of Culture, Media and Sport's strategic objectives, while including reference to increased access, make no mention of the accompanying need for conservation of our cultural heritage””." This is not the right occasion to philosophise on why the department is so unsatisfactory, other than the fact that it is not a great, traditional department of state and consists of rather ill-assorted components. The fact that it does not work well we must leave to discuss on another occasion. It is true that in the field of heritage and conservation its constituents are of widely different backgrounds and disciplines; a list of those who gave evidence to us reflects that. Moreover, the variety of sciences and technologies involved is unexpected, impressive and—to me—fascinating. Nothing fits neatly, but that is an added attraction and challenge, though perhaps not for officials. All this gives background to our first and principal conclusion, at paragraph 9.2, namely that our cultural heritage, both for funding and cultural reasons, is severely under threat. We end by asserting that the DCMS, "““has hitherto failed to grasp the scale of this threat—indeed, probably does not know it exists””—" a point made by many speakers this afternoon. For the rest of my contribution this afternoon, I shall concentrate on three points that are for me the backbone to our report, leaving aside the problem of the department itself and the funding issue. The points are: the role and status of the chief scientist; the relationship of the sector to the research councils; and the need for an overall management strategy. On the matter of the chief scientist, to which many noble Lords have referred this afternoon, we were clear that the department does not have the expertise to act as an intelligent customer of science, and what is needed is someone to act as a champion. I recall vividly the wise words of Neil MacGregor on this, when he gave evidence to us. We regard this as an essential prerequisite if the downgrading of conservation is to be reversed. What was the Government’s response? They said that such an appointment was by no means straightforward—et cetera, et cetera—and made an interim appointment. Can the Minister tell us when the full appointment will be made? The noble Lord, Lord Broers, asked whether Dr Dixon’s report has been presented. I hope that the Minister will be able to shed some light on all that. On the relationship with the research councils, our observations fortunately received a warm welcome from Research Councils UK. There appears to be a genuine commitment from AHRC in taking this forward. Thank goodness that the remit of the DCMS does not run to the research councils. As for our suggestion that English Heritage should provide the secretariat to carry forward the development of a national strategy for heritage science, the Government’s reply is a masterpiece of Whitehall obfuscation: ““On the one hand, this, and on the other hand, that””—a textbook reply from Whitehall. English Heritage, in contrast, made a warm response. We also said that it was important for the strategy to be developed bottom-up with considerable input from the users and doers, which produced a warm response from the National Trust. The NT has, of course, unrivalled experience but, in the nature of things, cannot have its own research capability and therefore looks to collaborative arrangements. It cited the work at Blickling Hall, which the committee visited, as a successful example of how things are and could be done. I have commented on the Government’s response to these three main points. But how, taken in the round, would someone summarise the totality ofthe response? I cannot match the knockabout stuff of the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, with which I totally agreed. It has been described as a bit of a curate’s egg, the warm welcome for research councils contrasting with the regular departmental response which, at almost every point, was grudging and lacking in substance. The contrast with the comments we received from the client sector is marked: they were almost unanimously enthusiastic. I shall confine myself to a single comment from Icon: "““The most worrying aspect of the DCMS response is that it fails to explicitly acknowledge that there is a problem””." I started off in a critical vein, and seem to be ending in the same way. I am not alone in that this afternoon. Nevertheless, against all the odds, and contrary to the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, perhaps the Minister will be able to get the Comprehensive Spending Review to come riding to our rescue because, my goodness, we need it.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 692 c67-9GC
- Session
- 2006-07
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords Grand Committee
- Subjects
- Conservation Cultural heritage Finance English Heritage Museums and galleries Staff Technology Research Science Department for Culture, Media and Sport Arts and Humanities Research Council Government Chief Scientific Adviser
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-15 12:46:48 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_402205
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_402205
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_402205