Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Howard of Rising (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 12 June 2007. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on Science and Heritage (Science and Technology Committee Report).


Science and Heritage (Science and Technology Committee Report)

My Lords, as Members of the Committee have already said, the committee is to be congratulated on producing a comprehensive report with some extremely fine analysis. It sets out the background so well with the excellent statement on the value of heritage to the nation. Good though the report is, and with respect to my noble friend Lady Hooper, I am unsure about the necessity for a chief scientific adviser. Among the many good points raised, the report highlights the inherent conflict between conservation and access. With no access, conservation is much simpler, but generally speaking there is little point in conserving something for it not to be seen. Thus the science of conservation becomes more and more important as more and more people take an interest in and want to see, and be in touch with, this nation’s heritage. Before going further I declare two interests. I am the owner of a medieval castle that lacks its main roof—something that has given me all too good an insight into one act of conservation. I am also chairman of the trustees of a 17th century almshouse. The advance of technology, as well as bringing new benefits, brings new problems. For example, a great benefit is the ability to provide instant virtual reality through the use of portable DVD players and computers, which has meant that the disabled can get more enjoyment when access is difficult or impossible. A problem arose at York Minster when no one could understand why, after centuries, a particular flagstone was being worn away. Eventually it was discovered that the electronic wand on which you pressed the number displayed at various points to get the relevant commentary gave the instruction, ““Take a step back, turn round and look up””. All were doing as instructed at exactly the same spot, with the consequent erosion of the flagstone. There was not a lot of science to resolve this—an example of the variety of problems that need solving. Many or most of these problems will need scientific input to find a solution. Multiply that huge number of problems by the diversity of different artefacts, living and dead, to which those problems apply, and you have an almost limitless number of problems with an unimaginable range. Think of the different requirements of Kew Gardens, referred to by my noble friend Lord Eccles, the British Library or, as my noble friend Lord Waldegrave mentioned, the ““Flying Scotsman””. Given that range and diversity, it is questionable whether a chief scientific adviser, as suggested by the report, would be able to make a meaningful contribution. Perhaps it would be better to pursue the DCMS’s line of argument that it would be more efficient for decisions to be delegated to the experts in the bodies that it sponsors. Unlike some other noble Lords, I believe that it is disappointing that the DCMS has been so quick to accept the idea of a chief scientific adviser. What would the point be of, say, English Heritage having to refer to or consult a scientific conservation adviser? As Sir Neil Cussons said: "““English Heritage is, of course, a conservation body and so conservation is at the heart of what we do””." Concern about dissemination seems obsolete in these days of the internet. Those working in preservation want to preserve—it is what they do—and, in pursuit of this, they will take advantage of the new sources of information that are growing so rapidly. The process is accelerating all the time, to the extent that the availability of information and the ease with which it can be achieved changes on an almost daily basis. Generally speaking, creating another layer of bureaucracy is not a success. The example of which we are all aware is the National Health Service, in which managers now outnumber hospital beds and doctors. The appointment of a chief scientific adviser to the DCMS, with appropriate staff—and what a multitude of sins ““appropriate staff”” might cover, when one considers the numbers that would be needed to advise competently on the massive range and diversity to which I have referred—would absorb funds that would be much better spent on the actual science or conservation by those carrying out conservation rather than by those overseeing or reviewing it. As the report says, the DCMS does not have the expertise to act as an ““intelligent customer”” of science. I am sure that that is correct, but why does it need to be an intelligent customer of science? The report makes clear that there is already an army of highly intelligent and knowledgeable customers who need no help to appreciate the value of heritage science. Where would the staff come from for the DCMS? As the noble Baroness, Lady Sharp, mentioned, the report comments on the shortage of skilled people, so if the DCMS is to be an intelligent customer, it will presumably have to recruit from the very organisations that it is seeking to help. I very much hope that whenDr Michael Dixon’s report appears, it will dismiss the idea of what would, in due course, become an expensive layer of bureaucracy. Reading the report, it is clear there are many organisations with great expertise in conservation. Is that very decentralisation and diversification, where each organisation has a strong focus on its particular specialist needs, in fact responsible for this country being a world leader in conservation? Each organisation has unrivalled knowledge in its sphere, which has been responsible for the success achieved. If money is to be spent to improve conservation science, it should be given directly to the relevant organisations to continue and enhance their work. They know what they are doing. They have the relevant expertise and, with added funds, could afford to carry out training programmes and disseminate their knowledge as the report recommends. There is strong evidence of a willingness to go along this path, as the noble Lord, Lord Clement-Jones, pointed out, for example, in English Heritage, the Arts and Humanities Research Council and the Institute of Conservation. That is all happening and is, no doubt, influenced by the report. The committee is to be congratulated on having initiated this action through its report. There is no need for further overhead creation. Money must go directly to the various bodies that know how to spend it. If there is a need for an overarching strategy—and I query that, with the huge diversity I have referred to—it should be entrusted to English Heritage, or a similar body where a lot of the relevant expertise already exists, rather than creating a new department at the DCMS that will have to acquire the same knowledge from scratch. I am afraid that we now come back to the old chestnut that we have debated so much recently: the appropriation of lottery funds for the Olympics. If just a modest proportion of those funds was made available to heritage, as was the original intent, the science of conservation could be developed and enhanced—not perhaps to everyone’s heart’s content, but certainly in a way that would satisfy noble Lords who have spoken today, and with no need for any new layers of bureaucracy.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
692 c74-7GC 
Session
2006-07
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Conservation Cultural heritage Finance English Heritage Museums and galleries Staff Technology Research Science Department for Culture, Media and Sport Arts and Humanities Research Council Government Chief Scientific Adviser
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk