Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Gordon Prentice (Labour) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 5 December 2007. It occurred during Estimates day on Standards of Conduct in Public Life.


Standards of Conduct in Public Life

That brings me neatly to a point that I was going to make later. It is all very well for the Government to say—I think that they say it in their response to the Select Committee report—that the ethical regulators are independent. However, if the Government of the day can cut the budget by 40 per cent. or 50 per cent., the idea of independence becomes fanciful. That is why we propose that the ethical regulator should be set up at arm's length from the Government and that the responsibility for its funding, starting and operation should be given to the public standards commission—the arm's length body that would report to Parliament. I should like to spend a couple of minutes on the key recommendations of our report; my friend the Member for Cannock Chase has alluded to them already. We believe that the ethical regulators should be permanent. They should not be able to be abolished by ministerial fiat, and there should be no going back to the position of the Government being able to decide on a whim that they want to abolish a regulator. The Minister could tell the House this afternoon that the House of Lords Appointments Commission or the Civil Service Commission were going to be abolished. Any of those bodies, which were set up not by statute but by the Prime Minister under prerogative powers, can be abolished. That is wrong—they should be set up on a statutory basis. I welcome the fact that we are going to have a civil service Act, but what a dance of the seven veils we have had over it. In July 1998, the Government said on the record for the first time that we would get such an Act, and 10 years later we just might—I hope so. The second and third characteristics of the regulator should be neutrality and independence. It cannot be right that bodies that regulate the Government in some way are accountable to the Government, and that should change. On the Government's response to our report, it is a big step forward for them to accede to our recommendation that constitutional watchdogs should have single non-renewable terms—that is self-evidently the right thing to do—but many of their other responses are opaque. It is not clear what will end up in the constitutional renewal Bill, but it is a big opportunity for the Government to look closely at how the ethical landscape can be reshaped. The Committee has made one proposal; there may be others. The system should be put into a legislative form, and the opportunity to do so will occur when the Bill is introduced early next year.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
468 c876-7 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Codes of practice Conduct Civil service Committee on Standards in Public Life Ethics Public appointments Politics and government Public service Ministers Standards Regulation Public Administration Select Committee
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk