Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Haskel (Labour) in the House of Lords on Friday, 14 March 2008. It occurred during Debate on select committee report on EU: Single Market (EUC Report).


EU: Single Market (EUC Report)

My Lords, it has been a privilege to serve on EU Sub-Committee B for the past three years. I thank my colleagues for their companionship, our chairmen for their leadership, our Clerks for their diligence and our special advisers for their support. We have conducted many inquiries, but I have little hesitation in saying that this is probably the most important. It is important because it is an inquiry not into any particular sector of the single market but into the Commission’s review of the whole single market itself. As we say in our report, the single market is often referred to as one of the greatest achievements of the European Union. To many, the European Union is the single market. I was pleased that we undertook this inquiry, because supporters, such as me, of the European Union were becoming concerned that progress towards completing the single market and the free movement of goods, capital, people and services was losing momentum. Others who may be a little less enthusiastic than I am about the European Union have interpreted this slowing down as a sign of decline. Had they been with me on my recent visit to the United States, even they would have been impressed with the high esteem that the EU enjoys there. In the course of several informal engagements, I was told how the European dream is replacing the American dream. People are queuing up to join. I was told how they admired the politics of consensus between the member states. I was also told that Europe—the EU—is the world’s largest public aid donor and how it more cleverly uses aid packages instead of sanctions. There is no sign of decline there, and I was not looking for compliments. Quite rightly, Mr Barroso and our Government continually warn that failure to take steps towards completing the single market provides room for protectionism to creep in. They are right, so we should never lose the opportunity to point out that the greatest champions for open and liberal markets in the single market are the UK Government and the European Commission. This is why the Commission is determined to act over the slow-down in the development of the single market. Our work, as the noble Lord, Lord Freeman, explained, was to examine its proposals. It soon became obvious that what was lacking was not legislation or more rules but implementation. The rules to complete the single market are all in place. It is their implementation which is needed to encourage cross-border activity by businesses large and small—this to give all EU citizens the economic benefits of the single market. As the noble Lord, Lord Freeman, explained, we rejected more centralised bureaucracy. Instead, we recommended practical instruments, such as: assistance in the transposition of EU laws and their enforcement; better information about what the rules really are; quicker and easier problem-solving by means of SOLVIT and other schemes; better regulation by raising standards in poorly regulated member states; enforcement to liberalise markets; and perhaps even enlargement to shake up some of the older member states. The final report of the Commission last November shares many of these proposals, and so does the Government’s response to our inquiry. I, too, add my thanks to those of the noble Lord, Lord Freeman, to the Government for their quick response. We looked at three specific sectors—energy, telecoms and financial services—to see how this would work. The key to liberalising the energy market is of course unbundling; since our report was written, the Commission has struck a deal with E.ON, the large German electricity and gas group—a deal that should pave the way to the far-reaching liberalisation of Europe’s energy market and is just the kind of imaginative use of instruments that we call for in our report. In telecoms, separation is the key. No European-wide regulator is needed; better national regulation is what we recommend. In financial services, we were concerned about a competitive market for the individual citizen. We should perhaps have been a little bit more concerned about tax and credit. I understand that nine member states are now discussing a pilot project to run a voluntary common consolidated tax base—again, the kind of co-operative instrument that should improve cross-border trade. During our inquiry, we paid attention to the progress of the services directive, particularly, as the noble Lord, Lord Freeman, told us, in its effect on SMEs. We felt that this was important because the Federation of Small Businesses told us that nearly 80 per cent of its members are in the services sector, but only 2 per cent engage in cross-border business. This probably applies to the rest of Europe. On several occasions, the committee has emphasised the importance of the services sector to British business. We were unhappy about the watering down of the original country of origin principle, but nevertheless concluded that the final services directive in December 2006 should be strongly supported. In its paper, the Commission also emphasised the importance of engaging SMEs in the single market. As most SMEs are in the services sector, it must follow that the successful implementation of the services directive must play an important part in completing the single market. In their response, the Government say that they support moves, "““to make it easier for SMEs to operate in the single market””." Central to this is the obligation for each member state to set up a website where businesses, particularly SMEs, would be able to learn of the requirements needed to provide a temporary service in other member states. The website should also enable them to complete any formalities. Without this facility, any awareness-raising of the business opportunities available to our service companies in other member states will be pointless. Easy access to this information is essential, and so is its quality. I therefore hope that the committee will keep an eye not only on what DBERR is doing in this regard, but most importantly on what other member states are doing to set up this facility for use by British service companies. In our report, we recommended that citizens be more fully persuaded of the benefits of the single market. The Government think so too, and so does the Commission. Its paper strongly emphasises that the main beneficiary for completing the single market should be the consumer. I agree. The consumer needs to be convinced of the economic benefits gained through more competition and higher standards, and they should have the right to make their voice heard. However, my impression while we conducted the inquiry was that, although the single market is incomplete, the consumer already takes it for granted. In their eyes, additional economic benefits will be marginal. My impression, which seems to be confirmed by surveys carried out by the Commission, is that what the European citizen now values most about the single market are the freedoms—the freedom to move around, to work, to study, to travel, to live, to get married and to set up home without any barriers or formalities anywhere in the Union. Many are taking advantage of this. These social benefits as much as the economic benefits will win the hearts and minds of European citizens and persuade them of the benefits of the single market. I hope that the Government and your Lordships’ committee will remember this, because this may turn out to be the most important point to come out of our inquiry.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
699 c1682-4 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Competition Energy Financial services EU internal trade EU action Telecommunications Transport Small businesses Regulation Treaty of Lisbon
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk