Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Baroness Morgan of Drefelin (Labour) in the House of Lords on Monday, 2 June 2008. It occurred during Debate on bill on Sale of Students Loans Bill.


Sale of Students Loans Bill

My Lords, I thank both noble Baronesses for their contributions to this thought-provoking debate. I stress that the rationale behind these amendments is very much about creating a process for the sale of the student loans book that will be long-lasting and sufficiently flexible to meet the Government’s needs both in the near future and for some years ahead. I do not wish to speculate on how many months or years the first sale of the student loans portfolio might take under the Bill if it is enacted as it would be inappropriate for me to do so. However, the noble Baroness, Lady Verma, is right to be concerned about Eurostat and the review of the guidance. Eurostat is reviewing its guidance, but it may periodically conduct other reviews. So even if we await the outcome of this review, there could be others. That is why the sales arrangers—Deutsche Bank—have advised that it would be appropriate for us to have the possibility of reducing the uncertainty around the sales process, to promote value for money and have the prospect of making the undertakings. I understand the concerns of the noble Baroness, Lady Sharp, in principle, but we need to remember that the Government are responsible for policy around student finance. If the Government were to make undertakings to fix the terms and conditions for a student loan that was sold, and if in the future a Government wished to look at the financial circumstances of the cohort of students with sold student loans, there would be many instruments for them to use to do so. Remember that they are not commercial loans but loans providing students with funding, which they then repay in real terms at the same level at which they originally borrowed. The provisions are not unreasonable for a loan so taken out. We are talking about a government process for making it possible for students to take the considerable benefits that a higher education offers and make the most of them. I stress for the noble Baroness that, should a future Government wish to make the financial circumstances of students with sold loans more favourable, many instruments would be open to them to do so, looking at the whole of the student finance and benefit system and whatever other ideas might be at their disposal. We are talking about the potential for undertakings specifically for sold loans, not for unsold loans. However, we are also talking about Amendment No. 6, which is important. It seeks to ensure that borrowers will not be in a worse position as a consequence of their loan being sold. That is not just about loans being made following undertakings, but about all loans sold. Given the clarifications and commitments that we have made regarding value for money and future options for government, I hope very much that noble Lords will support the amendments. We are ensuring that no student will be adversely affected as a result of their loan being sold, through this group of amendments. I hope that the House will support that. On Question, amendment agreed to. Clause 3 [Onward sales]:


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
702 c57-8 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Compensation Cost effectiveness Graduates Privatisation Public expenditure Loans Regulation Students
Legislation
Sale of Student Loans Bill 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk