Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Alderdice (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 21 January 2009. It occurred during Question for short debate on Israel and Palestine: Gaza.


Israel and Palestine: Gaza

My Lords, I do not think that anyone who looks at what has happened in Gaza over the past few weeks—seeing hundreds of thousands of people herded into a territory where they do not particularly want to be, with traditional weapons, white phosphorus and so on showered around them; children and women damaged not just in the short term but permanently with psychological and physical scars—will not feel distressed, unless they have themselves begun to lose something of their humanity. The last time that I was in Israel I spoke to an Israeli mother. She said to me, ““I desperately hope that my son in the IDF does not kill a Palestinian, because it will not help the Palestinian to be killed, and it will also damage my son””. She understood that the obvious humanitarian disaster of somewhere like Gaza destroys not only the Palestinian people but also terribly damages those who inflict the wounds, whatever they think they may be doing to help themselves or their state. It also means that the rest of us who stand by wringing our hands—or wearily, hopelessly shaking our heads when we could be doing something such as throwing in a few million pounds which we know will be destroyed again quickly—will also have lost some of our humanity. The noble and learned Lord, Lord Woolf, said that it is important to be objective and human. I ask the Minister whether he will look at one objective report, not of this particular crisis but of the cost of the Middle East conflict since the failure of Oslo, a report which was launched today in your Lordships’ House. This report shows the loss in human, environmental, psychological, political, cultural and economic terms—costs which are eye-watering in every way that one means that term—so that all of us can objectively but humanly shoulder our responsibility in making a difference for good.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
706 c1739 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Access Armed conflict Closures Bombings Buildings Development aid Casualties Civilians Borders Humanitarian aid United Nations War crimes Israel Palestine Middle East Reconstruction Peace negotiations Gaza Hamas White phosphorus Ceasefires
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk