---

Apprenticeships, Skills, Children and Learning Bill

I am grateful to all the noble Lords who have spoken on these amendments, and indeed to the Minister for trying so valiantly to respond. However, we feel that inclusion of this information will encourage employers, and others involved, to aim for higher and higher standards. I detected an element of agreement from the noble Baroness, Lady Wall, on that point. We also think that the very least that can be expected is that the certificate should say, on its face, that the qualification has been successfully completed. My noble friend Lord Lucas spoke about university degrees. It is proposed that these certificates will not even say that the qualification has been successfully completed. Because I have not heard a satisfactory answer from the Minister, I would like to test the opinion of the Committee. Division on Amendment 9. Contents 38; Not-Contents 40. Amendment 9 disagreed.