Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Nia Griffith (Labour) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 3 November 2011. It occurred during Debate on Commission on Devolution in Wales.


Commission on Devolution in Wales

I hope very much indeed that that bilateral work is progressing quickly and effectively. It is small wonder, given the Conservatives' track record on devolution, that many Opposition Members have expressed suspicions about the Government's motives for setting up the Silk commission. There are suspicions that the Government might be trying to sell Wales short and push through measures that would seriously disadvantage Wales. The concentration of wealth creation in London and south-east England means not only in Wales but in Scotland, Northern Ireland and the other regions of England that public expenditure is greater than the income from those areas, which are all net beneficiaries of the UK tax regime, while London and parts of the south-east and East Anglia are net contributors. That is for historical reasons, including the early emergence of London as the commercial capital and its importance as a world financial centre, and it is in contrast to other European countries, where the importance of the city state and, much later, unification has produced different patterns of wealth distribution. The disparities have existed in the UK for many years: they are deeply embedded and cannot simply be eliminated by a few years of regional policy or European funding, helpful as that is to compensate for the differences. Nor can they simply be eliminated by substantial growth in the private sector, vital as that is to Wales and across the UK. With such deep-seated historical differences in wealth distribution, complete financial independence for Wales, as advocated by Plaid Cymru, is an absolute non-starter. With a gap of £14.6 billion between public spending and the revenue raised in Wales, it would mean every man, woman and child in Wales contributing an extra £4,800—nearly £5,000 each a year just to maintain current levels of spending.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
534 c1198 
Session
2010-12
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Accountability Devolution Cross border cooperation Public consultation National Assembly for Wales Public expenditure Wales Taxation Commission on Devolution in Wales
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk