---

Official Controls (Amendment) Regulations 2024

My Lords, first, I thank the Minister for her usual generous response and the way she has handled all these SIs, where a lot of what is being said is outside her responsibility. We are very grateful as Members from Northern Ireland that she is willing to meet us so regularly to discuss some of the detail, even if, at the end, she is not able to change the substantial issue. Of course, we all know what it is.

The noble Baroness, Lady Anderson of Stoke-on-Trent, is in her place. I thank her for the way that she reached out to all the Northern Ireland Peers after the very bad storm to ask how we were. I thought that was a very nice gesture, and I thank her.

This has been an interesting debate. In my contribution, I was very technical and rushed to get it all in, so I am very grateful that Members sat and listened to that. I think we had a very good wider debate, as we always do when we discuss anything about Northern Ireland. I am particularly interested in what the noble Lord, Lord Frost, said, and I remind Members, if they have already forgotten—I hope they have remembered—that on Friday it will be five years since we left the European Union. I say “left”. Northern Ireland has not left, and that is still part of the thing, so when the noble Baroness, Lady Suttie, continues to say that it is all about Brexit, Northern Ireland has not had Brexit, although some of us have.

The thing that has most encouraged me over a number of SIs is how things have been changing. Originally, the Conservatives voted against any change to statutory instruments, and then on the previous vote, they abstained. Tonight, I understand that it is a free vote, so who knows what will happen the next time we have a statutory instrument? I say to noble Lords that we are going to continue to put these issues. It is the only place we get a proper debate.

I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Murphy of Torfaen, and thank him for sitting through all this tonight. I hope that it has helped in his inquiry and that he will reach out to all of us—particularly those of us who are not necessarily in a particular political party in Northern Ireland—during his look at how the Windsor Framework is working.

I thank all noble Lords. I agree with what the noble Lord, Lord Dodds, said about how we must have hope and look to change, and that we cannot take an attitude. I am never going to take an attitude of, “Well, this is happening. We’ve got to put up with it. Why don’t we just get on with it?”, which I am afraid is what one or two noble Lords say. We are not going to do that. Particularly as many members of the Government have been kept behind tonight—I hope, to listen—I am going to press a vote, because I want to get it on the record.