Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Smith of Clifton (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Monday, 4 July 2005. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Budget (No.2) (Northern Ireland) Order 2005.


Budget (No.2) (Northern Ireland) Order 2005

I, too, thank the noble Lord, Lord Rooker, for introducing the Budget order, but I must reiterate my oft-stated and long-held view that this is a very unsatisfactory way of scrutinising Northern Ireland legislation. It is cursory because of insufficient time, and undemocratic because it is not amenable to amendment, so that it is more a matter of form than of substance. In effect what we do when we consider the multitude of orders that constitute Northern Ireland legislation is to look—with few exceptions, when Ministers may intervene—at civil servants’ rule. When I recently made that point to the Secretary of State at an informal meeting with him and Peers who are especially interested in Northern Ireland, he said that his Ministers would exercise a strong influence over government policy. With the best will in the world, and fully accepting Mr Hain at his word, the small ministerial team and the very extensive range of government business means that, for all practical purposes, most policies are drawn up by the Civil Service. Northern Ireland civil servants do their best, but it is near impossible for us to assist their work by the means currently at our disposal. In parenthesis, I want to cite just one of my experiences that illustrate inefficiency in the Civil Service. Last Monday I received the usual mountain of mail from Belfast, as no doubt did other noble Lords. In my opinion it was bigger than it should have been. I was sent two copies of the Draft Employment (Miscellaneous Provisions) (Northern Ireland) Order from the Department of Employment and Learning; two copies of the consultation on the draft regulations implementing the new EU procurement directives from the Department of Finance and Personnel; two copies of a letter concerning the Electricity and Gas (Determination of Turnover for Penalties) Order (Northern Ireland) from the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Investment; and two copies of the Industrial Training Levy (Construction Order) (Northern Ireland), again from the Department of Employment and Learning. Other departments succeeded in sending me only one. I have not had time to examine today’s post. These may seem trivial examples of waste, but how far are they symptomatic of a very generously financed system of government relative to that of the other parts of the UK? Under present conditions it is very difficult to find out. Furthermore, even if, as the Secretary of State said, Ministers are going to take a closer look at decisions, welcome though that is, it still means that the executive branch of government—which comprises both the permanent Civil Service and the ministerial element of transient politicians—proceeds essentially unencumbered by adequate parliamentary scrutiny. To be fair, that is acknowledged by Ministers. Whenever I have raised the subject, I have been assured that they are looking at it, but no remedies are suggested then by them. I doubt if this subject heretofore has absorbed much of their time. Therefore, I am very grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Rooker, for his preliminary statements today, and I hope that at long last the Government will come up with some positive suggestions for improving the situation. Having made those general remarks, I shall concentrate on one specific issue; namely, community relations policy and how it is translated through the Budget. My noble friend Lord Shutt of Greetland, as usual, will be asking probing financial questions relating to those aspects of the Budget order on which his accountant’s gimlet eye has alighted. Government policy in the framework document ““A Shared Future: The Framework for Good Relations in Northern Ireland”” was published in March this year, following a commitment given by the then Secretary of State to my honourable friend in another place in January during Northern Ireland Questions. This document followed a review of community relations in Northern Ireland by Dr Jeremy Harbison, whose report was published in January 2002, and a further government consultation. A Shared Future outlines realistically the scale of the challenge and indicates that good relations will be built on the significant progress of the equality agenda. The objectives outlined in A Shared Future include the elimination of sectarianism; the reduction of tension at interface areas; the facilitation of the development of a shared community where people wish to live, work, play and learn together; the promotion of civic mindedness via citizenship education; the protection of members of minorities; and the shaping of policies, practices and institutions to enable trust and good relations to grow. We on these Benches very much welcomed the publication of the framework document. Within it, there is an appreciation of the fundamental social, economic and financial costs arising from a divided society. The practical result of sectarian attitudes is that they manifest themselves as segregation. It is a de   facto practice on the ground with respect to education, housing and the delivery of services. In the public sector, housing has become much more segregated. In the vast majority of housing estates, fewer than 10 per cent of residents are regarded as coming from a perceived different section of the community. In education, only 5 per cent of children attend schools that are integrated in ethos. The Alliance Party has conducted research into how much the duplication of services costs in Northern Ireland. It believes that the economic impact of sectarianism amounts to £1 billion to the Northern Ireland taxpayer per annum. While we acknowledge that the situation will not change overnight and that this is long-term, challenging work, it is important that the debate moves on swiftly from the policy framework to practical changes in actual policy. In terms of policy action, community relations can no longer represent a small niche within public policy, but rather must be mainstreamed throughout the actions of all departments and public agencies. That is a major task. Can the Minister give a more precise breakdown of the amount of money allocated across the departments for the promotion of this policy? Can he tell us how much has been spent in the past 12 months and how much is forecast to be spent in the next 12 months on the provision of, and the promotion of, integrated housing both across Northern Ireland as a whole and within the area of each borough council? Furthermore, can he give us the same figures for integrated education? Finally, can he also give us figures on government investment in the voluntary sector, which does so much to promote good community relations on the ground in Northern Ireland?


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
673 c27-9GC 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Administration Civil servants Doctors Health services Finance Education Government departments EU grants and loans Northern Ireland Pensions Public expenditure Parliamentary scrutiny Northern Ireland government Voluntary organisations Teachers Tourism Tax rates and bands Waterways Ireland Ulster University
Legislation
Budget (No. 2) (Northern Ireland) Order 2005
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk