Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Lester of Herne Hill (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 19 October 2005. It occurred during Debate on bill on Equality Bill [HL].


Equality Bill [HL]

My Lords, like my noble friend I am glad that the Government have narrowed the exception in Amendment No. 141. All that I briefly want to deal with is why the independent Race Monitor could usefully be brought in to deal with religion in the context of the decisions taken under the amendment. The Race Relations Act goes beyond nationality. There is some extremely offensive stuff in there that would allow the Secretary of State to authorise racial discrimination against groups such as Roma or the Pontic Greeks, among others. I declare a professional interest because, in the Roma rights case, all that came up to the Law Lords and the Government did not rely on the authorisation made in that context. I agree; the stuff that I have just mentioned is unlawful and would be so, in effect, if ever used. That is why the Minister rightly focused on nationality, which is a much more acceptable form of discrimination, under immigration control. We have the independent Race Monitor, who is there as a check to give public confidence in the administration of immigration control. She is paid public money to perform that vital function, make annual reports and so on. We are now in a much more sensitive area than nationality discrimination. When deporting or turning away someone on religious grounds because, as individuals, they belong to an extremist, fundamentalist, religious organisation that is suspected of being a terrorist organisation or otherwise, we are dealing with one of the most sensitive issues. It would be in the interests of the Home Office, the immigration service and the public at large if the Race Monitor became a race and religious monitor, so that she is able to look at decisions which may, indeed, intertwine between race and religion in the case of ethnic minorities who also belong to a religious group, and the individual is considered to be someone who should not be allowed into the country or whose presence is not conducive to the public good. That is why our proposal is modest and is designed not to lead to litigation or anything of that kind but simply to enhance public confidence. Perhaps I may conclude by quoting Archbishop William Temple, who we used to quote many years ago. I am sorry that the bishops are not in their place at the moment. He once said:"““Whenever I travel on the underground, I always intend to buy a ticket, but the fact that I know that there is a ticket collector at the other end just clinches it””." I know that the Immigration Service intends to use its powers honestly and fairly and in a non-invidious manner. But the fact that there is a monitor to report on how it is working just clinches it.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
674 c855-6 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Disability Children Disclosure of information Codes of practice Age Disability Rights Commission Commission for Racial Equality Civil proceedings Equality Human rights Gender Equality and Human Rights Commission Equal Opportunities Commission Public appointments Monitoring Religion Sexuality
Legislation
Equality Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk