Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Eric Forth (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Friday, 17 March 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill on Climate Change and Sustainable Energy Bill 2005-06.


As amended in the Standing Committee, further considered.

I am grateful to my hon. Friend. I cannot understand the reason for the delay, especially as we have known about the Bill and the dates when it would be considered for a long time. I am not really a suspicious sort of chap, so I hope that I do not evince too much suspicion by hoping that the report was not delayed artificially because the promoter of the Bill and the Minister assumed that we would have completed our consideration. Things should have been the other way round. Fortunately, because the House has chosen to debate the Bill properly and in proper detail, our Third Reading may take place after we have the benefit of the report, which would be a huge advantage. I come again to section 82 of the Energy Act 2004, where subsection (6) states:"““For the purposes of this section ‘microgeneration’ means the use for the generation of electricity or the production of heat of any plant . . . which in generating electricity or (as the case may be) producing heat, relies wholly or mainly on a source of energy or a technology mentioned in subsection (7);””" and"““the capacity of which to generate electricity or . . . produce heat does not exceed the capacity mentioned in subsection (8).””" Those are important matters. We are starting to get to the heart of the definition of microgeneration, as originally set out in the 2004 Act and which would be affected by the measures we are discussing. Subsection (7) gives the usual list of preferred sources of energy:"““biomass . . . biofuels . . . fuel cells . . . photovoltaics . . . water (including waves and tides) . . . wind . . . solar power . . . geothermal sources . . . combined heat and power systems””" and, crucially,"““other sources of energy and technologies for the generation of electricity or the production of heat, the use of which would, in the opinion of the Secretary of State, cut emissions of greenhouse gases in Great Britain.””" I think, subject to correction, that the important distinction is that we are moving towards trying to establish whether microgeneration, in the context of climate change—which is, of course, the point of the Bill—is concerned only with renewables as such, or whether there should be a somewhat broader definition of sources of energy and technologies that would cut emissions of greenhouse gases. As I understand it, the two are not necessarily the same. Subsection (8) of section 8 notes that capacity is"““in relation to the generation of electricity, 50 kilowatts””" and"““in relation to the production of heat, 45 kilowatts thermal””." Given that the typical consumption of a household is between 1 and 3 kW at most, a 50 kW capacity is relatively large for a single domestic unit. That is something that we will have to come to in the context of a different group of amendments. In 2004, it certainly seemed clear not only that renewables were to be included in the definition of microgeneration, but that the definition could encompass sources that would cut emissions of greenhouse gases. There seem to be important differences between those provisions and amendments Nos. 51 and 52, in the Minister’s name. Amendment No. 51 repeats, in essence, the provisions in the Energy Act, noting that"““‘microgeneration means the use for the generation of electricity or the production of heat of any plant (which, for this purpose, includes any equipment, apparatus or appliance)—which, in generating electricity or (as the case may be) producing heat, relies wholly or mainly on a source of energy or a technology mentioned in subsection (2)””." The following subsection repeats the point about capacity. The energy sources are listed in amendment No. 52:"““biomass . . . biofuels . . . fuel cells . . . photovoltaics . . . water (including waves and tides) . . . wind . . . solar power . . . geothermal sources . . . combined heat and power systems””." That is crucially and, presumably, deliberately different from the definition in the Act, so the question arises: why have we lost the previous definition that allowed for other sources of energy"““which would, in the opinion of the Secretary of State””" cut emissions of greenhouse gases in Great Britain? That is an important question, which touches on the definition of microgeneration for that purpose. If we are now talking only about the second list, it eliminates, presumably deliberately, other possible sources of energy, either present or future.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
443 c1712-4 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Combined heat and power Climate change Environment protection Energy Electricity generation Ofgem Planning Scotland Wind power Carbon emissions Fuel cells
Legislation
Climate Change and Sustainable Energy Bill 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk