Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from John Pugh (Liberal Democrat) in the House of Commons on Monday, 20 March 2006. It occurred during Estimates day on Department of Health.


Department of Health

I apologise for the fact that my hon. Friend the Member for Northavon (Steve Webb) is not present. He would like to be here, but he is elsewhere working tirelessly for the public good on parliamentary business. As I am new, I am sure that hon. Members will excuse or perhaps even welcome the relative brevity of my contribution. I could be tempted into launching a Castro-like tirade in which, having acknowledged the additional funds that the Government have put in, I damn them for disproportionate increases in administration, public relations and publicity, failure to recognise the impact of wage settlements, gold-plating the European Union working time directive, vexing hospitals with politically driven targets, and generally fomenting a culture of change and instability that makes Mao Tse Tung’s permanent revolution seem a little tentative. However, that would only provoke Labour Back Benchers to point to the largesse of the Chancellor, falls in the waiting lists and the fact that the net deficit is only about 1 per cent. Instead, let us cut to the quick and have the sensible debate that the right hon. Member for Rother Valley (Mr. Barron) requires us, and prompted us, to have. The basic problem with the NHS is how to run a non-profit-making, demand-led service and stick to expenditure limits. That is analogous to the problems that councils will be familiar with when dealing with social services departments—they always overrun, and it is very difficult to manage a demand-led service effectively. The Government’s first idea was to set targets, but reaching targets requires adequate resources. When resources are not adequate, targets are often achieved by adopting perverse methods, or displacing equally worthwhile goals. The second Government idea, which was embodied in the Healthcare Commission, is the perfectly legitimate idea of pursuing a strategy of assessing clinical outputs in relation to resource allocation. By itself that is not a bad idea, but the key question is how it is pursued. Global figures on the whole NHS are no good. They are relatively uninformative; they tell us something and they are very useful in Prime Minister’s questions and so on, but they do not provide a fine-grained picture. Even at strategic health authority and regional level, they are relatively unilluminating, as there will be a lot of funds sloshing around between one cost centre and another. The Government appear to have pursued a policy that concentrates on individual cost centres: primary care trusts, hospitals and so on. In some senses this is a new departure, and they have done it in a way that has revealed substantial and worrying variations, and considerable deficits. The moot question for all of us is whether the issue is new and recently discovered, or whether it has previously existed in one form or another, perhaps disguised in the past by sloppy accountancy or the ability to move finance from year to year. It has certainly been disguised by extensive use of brokerage, whereby the SHA would find money for those in deficit and bail them out at the end of the year, and sometimes by plain misdescription of activity, whereby a shortage of secondary care might be dealt with by using some money allocated to primary care, which is then called secondary care.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
444 c85-6 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Health services Finance Government departments NHS Public expenditure Department of Health
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk