Proceeding contribution from Lord Harrison (Labour) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 18 May 2006. It occurred during Debate on EU Constitutional Treaty.
EU Constitutional Treaty
My Lords, I, too, would like to thank the noble Lord, Lord Blackwell, for beginning this debate but I would like to challenge some of the myths for which I think he is also responsible. Like the noble Lord, Lord Anderson, I think that there is a hidden agenda of wanting to leave the European Union. We should ask ourselves what would happen were the United Kingdom to do so. The very next day we would start negotiations again either with the European Union or with the other 24 or 26 countries within it to find satisfactory arrangements for a market. I asked the Norwegian ambassador recently whether it was a disadvantage for Norway to be outside the European Union and the single market. He said that there were at least four items that he could name where, had Norway had an influence on how the market was being composed, it would have been better for Norway. As for the fanciful idea of the noble Lord, Lord Blackwell, that we should somehow liberate the FSA, make it a free trade option and then London would dictate to the rest of Europe how financial services were accomplished, that is truly fanciful. The second myth that I would like to challenge is the one that the French and Dutch ““no”” was a no to the constitution. Incidentally, 15 countries have said yes to that constitution. The French vote was clearly anti-government and there were clearly concerns about globalisation, de-localisation and social protection. However, I should say to the Minister that I am not certain about Angela Merkel’s proposal of including a statement on social protection as a way forward. It could open a Pandora’s box of other countries wanting to intrude their own changes into the system. As for the Dutch, it may well have been a fear of loss of identity and in-migration. However, I hope your Lordships have had the opportunity to read the splendid reports by the Item club and also by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, which acknowledged the wisdom of the United Kingdom Government in welcoming workers here immediately from the 10 accession countries. They computed that the interest rate has been kept down by 0.5 per cent, that these new workers are doing jobs that others will not do, that 33 per cent of them are actually not just in low paid jobs but in business administration, that they have dispersed to all parts of the country thereby fulfilling the need for jobs and work elsewhere in the United Kingdom and, ultimately, they have been helping provide pensions for our older folk, because we need new, young, vibrant people to contribute to our economy over the coming years. It may well be that we would lose a referendum in the United Kingdom at the moment, but we should remind ourselves why that might be the case. We have had a deformed debate. The period of reflection has been more a period of deflection away from the issues. We have a problem with the press and the media. We have a splendid European Union Committee scrutiny system here in your Lordships’ House, but too often those reports are disregarded. However, if we have an item on the agenda concerning the threats to the production of organ pipes in English churches, we get full publicity in the whole of the press. The fact that the directive is a good one, concerned about lead content, and that the issue is entirely overblown and taken out of proportion, skips by. We should not be guilty of contributing to muddying the waters of a proper debate. Why are some noble Lords against the constitution? We are told for instance that the constitution will simplify to a single text. The noble Lord, Lord Blackwell, said that it was described as a tidying-up exercise. Broadly speaking, I am in favour of tidying-up exercises if one of the results is that we have a simple text that is transparent. They also want to abandon the idea of having a president of council and not to abandon the six-month presidency. Adopting a president would give consistency, clarity and continuity—surely something again of benefit to the European Union. We were proposing to have a European Union foreign affairs Minister so that we do not punch below our weight, which is the case at the moment. We would introduce a new system of double majority voting, which would actually strengthen the opportunity for larger countries such as the United Kingdom. Why are the Euro-sceptics against that? QMV was to be extended to 15 new areas. That would be good news for British business, because it would mean that the veto could not be used by other countries against the United Kingdom in those vital areas of creating, establishing and extending the single market. Why are our colleagues opposite against the explicit provision to be able to withdraw from the European Union? Most important of all is the proposal that we, the national Parliament, should have a greater role through the subsidiarity mechanism, which is something that we pronounced on in our special European Union committee. That is also apparently to be set aside. What a strange business from the Opposition. What should we do? First, we should publicise and explain better exactly those ideas that are enshrined in the constitution, and make it part of a vibrant and proper debate. Then we should do what can be done without treaty change. That is sometimes described as cherry picking. I like cherries and I think that we should pick cherries from time to time. For example, if we could institute Council transparency, why not go ahead and do so? If we can reinstitute that idea of subsidiarity scrutiny which is done so well in your Lordships’ House in an informal way, why not do so? Chancellor Merkel has provided an opportunity with the forthcoming German presidency beginning next year. She has said that she wants to persuade a sceptical public of the bonuses of jobs, housing and other items. That is where I arrive towards the end of my speech. Like the noble Lord, Lord Dykes, I believe the essential task of the European Union is to complete the single European market, the Lisbon Agenda and items like the services directive, because that is the route to providing proper jobs and prosperity. I shall give one example that the noble Lord briefly mentioned. It has been computed by the London Economic Survey that if we were to have a mortgage credit market, it would be an advantage to the European Union, and therefore to consumers, of something like €91 billion. I heard the noble Lord, Lord Waddington, say that he was unable to attend a debate because he was waiting for the gasman. Here, too, the European Union can establish a proper energy market, not only for gas but also for oil and other items like wind power. Indeed, if he appreciates wind power from windmills, he can truly be proud of being a Dutchman.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 682 c398-400
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Constitutions Diplomatic service European Union Legislative competence EU internal trade European Constitution Treaty EU action EU institutions EU justice and home affairs Referendums Treaties Regulation UK membership of EU Charter of Fundamental Rights (EU) UK trade with EU
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-04-21 22:02:32 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_323104
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_323104
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_323104