Proceeding contribution from Lord Norton of Louth (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 8 June 2006. It occurred during Debate on Home Office.
Home Office
My Lords, I, too, congratulate my noble friend on initiating this debate. The Home Office faces a serious crisis. It has been the subject of extensive criticism. To say that is nothing new; criticisms have been levelled for decades. What is different this time round is, first, the scale of the criticism and, secondly, the fact that the acknowledgement that the Home Office, or part of it, is not fit for purpose has come from within—that is, from the Home Secretary. The Home Office is distinctive—though historically not unique—among government departments in constituting a department that is difficult to manage effectively. The reasons for this derive from the very form of the department. There are, essentially, four inherent problems: those of scale, range, nature and culture. By scale, I refer to the combined effect of the responsibilities borne by the Home Office. This derives from the origins of the department in 1782, when foreign affairs and home and colonial affairs became the basis of the separation between the two principal departments of state. Over time it has lost many of its responsibilities, becoming what A. Lawrence Lowell described, more than a century ago, as a ““sort of residual legatee””. However, even with the loss of many responsibilities, those that remain have grown in their scope and the department is still one of the biggest in Whitehall. By range, I refer to the disparate nature of the tasks. Though less disparate than before, they still cover a wide range. The noble Lord, Lord Ramsbotham, has already identified them so I shall not repeat them. Some of these are the responsibility of particular agencies, bureaux or services. We have a number of bodies within one umbrella department. By nature, I refer to the issues covered. They tend to be matters of immediate public concern, issues which can create problems that loom up to dominate the political agenda. The late Lord Jenkins of Hillhead once observed that, when he was at the Treasury, changes could be foreseen some weeks ahead and were part of the general ebb and flow of events, whereas the climate at the Home Office was,"““one of tropical storms that blow up with speed and violence out of a blue sky, that dominate the political landscape for a short time, and then disappear as suddenly as they arrived””." The nature of the problems is such that the department tends to be in reactive mode, the proof of which is demonstrated by the Home Office Bills brought regularly before this House and designed to address the problem of the day—a point made by Lord Jenkins and Lord Callaghan. The position has doubtless changed over the years, but change can often be slow, especially in a department where, traditionally, the career of many civil servants has been confined to it. There are long-standing problems. Julian Amery once observed that it takes a good jockey to ride a difficult horse. The Home Office, for the reasons that I have given, is a difficult horse. However, it appears to have become more difficult in recent years. Despite the changes in the department, it has never really managed to keep pace with the scale of the problems it faces. This has been compounded by changes in relationships within government. As a result, the Home Office has never really been able to plan ahead on any clear, comprehensive scale. It has either been in response mode, dealing with the latest storm, or pursuing the latest initiative of the Home Secretary. There has been no clear conception of where the Home Office, as a home office, is going. Dean Acheson observed that Britain had lost an empire but had yet to find a role. The Home Office has shed many of its responsibilities without acquiring a clear sense of direction. It may have an idea of what it is for, but not necessarily of where it is going. What, then, is to be done? The problems that need to be addressed can be grouped under three headings: co-ordination, structure, and relationships. What has happened at the Home Office highlights wider issues of government. There is clearly a problem of co-ordination within the Home Office. This exists both horizontally and vertically. The greater differentiation of tasks within the department has provided, at least on the surface, more clearly defined responsibilities, but it has generated problems of communication between the different parts. It has also generated problems in overall co-ordination at ministerial level. It is not clear that the normal structure of a Secretary of State assisted by junior ministers has worked as it should. There is, for any new Secretary of State in government, inadequate training, guidance and dissemination of best practice in running a department. There may need to be clearer, more structured processes in place. The problem with structures is derived essentially from the origins of the Home Office. This residual legatee department has a clearer shape than previously, but it is derived largely from those functions that it has retained rather than from a detached reconfiguration of its role within government. I think there is a case for revisiting precisely what the role of the Home Office is or, rather, should be. As has already been mentioned, it has to be looked at alongside the role of other departments. We have a Department for Constitutional Affairs which has retained many of the attributes of a Lord Chancellor’s department. What is the relationship between the DCA and the Home Office? We have heard the various arguments for a ministry of justice and a department for homeland security, the case for which was made very powerfully by the noble Lord, Ramsbotham, and the noble Baroness, Lady Stern. On this matter, I side with the Cross-Benchers: there is a case for looking at a more rational structuring of departments. The third problem touches on the fundamentals of our system of government. Recent years have witnessed a failure by Ministers to appreciate the interdependencies at the heart of the political process. There have been conflicts between Home Secretaries and the courts. These have not been particular to this Government, although they appear to have reached a new level of intensity. There have been conflicts between Ministers and civil servants. There have been some high-profile cases, as in the Home Office, but there is a pervasive problem. Research I undertook some years ago into the role of senior Ministers found that mutual respect and the recognition of interdependency remained a feature of ministerial-Civil Service relationships. One can no longer draw that conclusion. That relationship remains in some cases, but the plates have shifted. The comments last week of Jonathan Baume, general secretary of the First Division Association, based on events in the Home Office, reiterated those which he had made previously. This problem is exemplified by the Home Office, but it is not particular to it. I have not offered detailed prescriptions for tackling the first two of these problems. They are problems for government. It is up to the Government to address them, and to be accountable to Parliament for what they have done. The third problem, though, is of a different nature. The glue that holds the different elements of our political system together is losing its adhesive strength. This erosion of relationships also has to be seen in the context of institutional fragmentation. Our constitution is undergoing major change without our having a clear sense of where we are going. We need to address the problem in the round. Having reflected on this for some time, I believe the time has come to establish a Royal Commission—in essence, a Royal Commission on the constitution—to make sense of what is happening and to offer proposals. I use today’s debate to put down a marker. Changes within the Home Office are necessary. For the reasons I have given, they will not be sufficient.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 682 c1455-7
- Session
- 2005-06
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords chamber
- Subjects
- Deportation ICT Immigration controls Undocumented migrants Foreign nationals Home Office National insurance Police Prisoners' transfers Prisoners Prisons Overcrowding Standards Reorganisation Open prisons
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2024-01-26 17:06:55 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_327972
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_327972
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_327972