Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Alun Michael (Labour) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 18 October 2006. It occurred during Debate on bill on Companies Bill (HL).


Companies Bill [Lords]

Many of my hon. Friends wish to speak, so I shall keep my remarks very brief. The speech of my hon. Friend the Member for Hemsworth touched on issues in which I have taken a passionate interest for many years. The only public meeting that I held at the time of the last general election was on the theme ““Poverty is political””, linked to the need to tackle poverty worldwide. I have been involved in fair trade issues for many years, and ministerial experience has taught me a great deal about how to make sustainable development a reality. Freedom from ministerial responsibilities allows me to take part in the debate, and to say frankly and openly what I think about the issues. I want a business environment in which the long-term interests of a company include consideration of its responsibility to people and to the environment, but I cannot support new clause 1 because I do not believe that it will have the desired effect. I agree with my hon. Friend about the ends, but great care must be taken with the means. My hon. Friend spoke of protecting the public interest and of the need for a light touch. He observed that corporate social responsibility was now taken seriously—and it is, because the environment has changed. I support the Government amendments because they respond to an aspect of our debates on these issues, but the new clause would introduce a serious bureaucratic burden without achieving the desired results. Surely we should all want the whole of business to be both successful and responsible, and the new environment of enlightened shareholder value encouraged by the Bill will have a major impact in that regard. The balance of success and responsibility is built into the Bill very carefully. In my view, the hon. Member for Cambridge (David Howarth) is wrong: a tick-box mentality is more likely to result in a PR tool than to encourage a positive change in the environment. The Bill embodies other important principles, such as ““Think small first””, which has been seven years in the making. The new clause has good intentions, but in practice it embodies the principle ““Think bureaucratic first””. It introduces a danger—companies will be advised by lawyers and they will play safe, not in protecting sustainable development, but in bureaucratic activity, producing more paperwork rather than public benefit. Gibbon has warned us that laws often fail to prevent what they forbid. I suggest that bureaucratic regulation often fails to achieve the desired outcome. There can be perverse, unintended consequences. What enlightened shareholder value does is allow more citizen engagement in how companies operate. Those of us who care about issues such as sustainable development and fair trade, and wish to combat exploitation, surely want an environment in which the citizen campaigner is complemented by the citizen consumer. We can now go into a shop and see half a dozen different fairly traded coffees, which was not the case a few years ago. We also want the citizen shareholder to have an impact. What we want is not a tick-box environment, but intelligent engagement by companies. That is where I agree with the hon. Member for Putney. The Bill retains ““true and fair”” as the accountancy standard, for instance, which is extremely important. I believe that enlightened shareholder value will allow organisations in the Corporate Responsibility Coalition—those who want to campaign for trade justice, environmental protection and the rest—to continue an intelligent engagement with business that has helped to increase responsibility in terms of sustainable development and international accountability in the United Kingdom, while at the same time making the UK a better place in which to do business. Surely there are lessons to be learned from our success in recent years in encouraging small companies to promote entrepreneurship. There may be things that companies should do to a greater extent in order to carry out their responsibilities, but some of them should be contained in employment, environment or health and safety legislation rather than a Bill that is concerned with the vehicle—the company. Moreover, there is nothing to prevent companies from reporting in a way that is not required by law if that proves useful to shareholders for reasons of transparency. It would be good for their reputations, demonstrating that they were working responsibly. Let us continue the partnership between Government and business and, indeed, the organisations that have campaigned for improvements. Let us think small first. Let us work on the application of enlightened shareholder value, which is making the UK a good and progressive business environment. Let us not go down the heavy-handed bureaucratic route that I fear is being proposed, although not intentionally, in the new clause and amendments.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
450 c908-9 
Session
2005-06
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Access Disclosure of information Animal welfare Accountability Company law Community development Companies Directors Business Annual reports Liability Donors Expenditure Exemptions Harassment Ethics Journalism Personal records Membership Political parties Public companies Loans Staff Meetings Private companies Lobbying Registration Trade unions Voting rights Shareholders Huntingdon Life Sciences Business plans
Legislation
Companies Bill (HL) 2005-06
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk