Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Ramsbotham (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 23 June 2009. It occurred during Question for short debate on Guantanamo Bay.


Guantanamo Bay

I take the opportunity of the gap to make a practical point on the Question raised so clearly and succinctly by the noble Lord, Lord Bridges. When I was the Chief Inspector of Prisons, I went to the special centre in Belmarsh where IRA terrorists were held. I was extremely concerned about the conditions in which they were held, but also about the staff who had to look after them. Noble Lords will remember that a number of Iraqis were put in Belmarsh without trial for a considerable time. Again, their conditions and treatment had not been pre-planned. Fortunately, there was an extremely able governor in Belmarsh who realised that this was not a normal imprisonment, of either a sentenced or unsentenced prisoner, but for an indefinite period. Again, there is the question of the staff who have to look after them. Obviously, this is a hypothetical question. We do not know if, or how many, people from Guantanamo may be returned to the United Kingdom. We do not know for how long they may have to be detained. My question to the Minister is simple, although I acknowledge that it is possibly more for the Ministry of Justice than the Home Office. Have the Government taken steps to identify the sort of conditions in which people like this ought to be held? To pitch them into a normal or high-security prison would be wholly inappropriate, bearing in mind where they have come from. Secondly, have the Government identified the special staffing measures required for psychiatric and other treatments from the time that they have been in that place? Have they taken steps to identify the sort of staff who might be suitable? Not all of them are. Have they taken steps to make certain that there is briefing and training for them before they go to where the prisoners are sent with the resources needed to look after them while they are there?


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
711 c417GC 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Detainees British overseas territories EU countries Finance Intelligence services Immigration Free movement of people National security Terrorism Torture USA Rendition Guantanamo Bay Bermuda
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk