Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Glentoran (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 21 October 2009. It occurred during Debates on delegated legislation on Welsh Ministers (Transfer of Functions) (No. 2) Order 2009.


Welsh Ministers (Transfer of Functions) (No. 2) Order 2009

My Lords, I thank the Minister for explaining the order and the consequential order to us. If I understand it correctly, they largely involve building regulations. I have spent a lot of my life—probably about 30 years of it—involved in and around building regulations, so I suppose that I must declare an interest, having worked for Redland as a buildings materials producer and then been a director of the NHBC. The purpose of the order is, as the Minister said, to transfer to the Welsh Ministers functions currently exercised by the Secretary of State under the Building Act 1984 and associated legislation. The Explanatory Memorandum indicates that the purpose of the proposed transfer is to help to advance the Welsh Assembly Government’s policies to tackle climate change. The Assembly Government intend to pursue even more stringent carbon reduction targets than those applicable in the rest of the country, and aim to achieve that by, inter alia, reducing still further the environmental impact of the building industry—a brave objective. To help to advance that policy, the Assembly Government consider it necessary to develop their own building regulations—another brave challenge. Although the pursuit of policy to tackle climate change is of course laudable, I am concerned that the creation of a different building regulations regime in Wales from that of England may have a severe impact on both the Welsh construction industry and Welsh house buyers. It appears self-evident that complying with more stringent building regulations will inevitably lead to greater costs on the building industry, which is at present already suffering grievously in Wales. Indeed, Redrow Homes, Wales's largest house building company, recently posted its worst ever set of results. The housing market in Wales is very fragile. It must be a concern that any additional costs that fall on house builders and are passed on to house buyers will have the effect of further depressing the market. At a time when the goal of increasing the supply of affordable housing is being pursued, it is hard to see that any proposal that has the effect of increasing the cost of houses will do anything to allay what is a serious problem, especially in rural Wales. It is a concern that, according to the Explanatory Memorandum, no impact assessment has been undertaken. The Minister will no doubt respond by saying that that matter should be left to the Assembly Government to conduct during the pre-measure stage. However, I note from the memorandum that engagement with industry and other stakeholders over potential changes to the regulations in Wales has actually begun. What initial responses have been received from the industry so far? Is it the case, as anecdotal evidence has it, that the response of the building industry to date has been wholly adverse? What do the Government propose to do to address the concerns of the industry? What initial assessment have the Government made about the likely additional cost to the industry of complying with the kind of regulations that are foreseen as a consequence of the Assembly Government’s policy? What assessment have the Government made of the likely impact of more stringent regulations on house prices, the housing market generally and, perhaps most important of all, the availability of affordable housing? What assessment have they made of the likely impact of the availability of mortgages? Do the Government recognise that with more stringent building regulations in place in Wales than in England there will be a significant incentive to Welsh builders to move their operations out of the Principality into England, which in the most populous parts of Wales is less than an hour down the road? What consideration have the Government given to the potential of more stringent regulations deterring English builders from pursuing building operations in Wales? The order provides for a commencement date of 31 December 2011, which according to the Explanatory Memorandum is intended to provide a lead-in period for the establishment of Welsh Assembly Government capacity for the transfer of functions and development and engagement work in respect of the first proposed changes to the building regulations. How satisfied is the Minister that the Welsh Assembly Government are able to build such additional capacity in time for the commencement date? The order provides for the establishment of a building regulation advisory committee for Wales and a separate committee for England. What assessment has been made of the effect of such separation on the capacity of the committee for England? What are the implications of such a separation? On costs generally, is it intended that any and all additional costs generated by the new Welsh regime will be absorbed by the Assembly out of the existing budget? As the Minister will gather from my questions, we on this side of the Committee have serious reservations about this proposal. Having spent a lifetime involved with building regulations, I would also like to know how long it took to reproduce the building regulations from Northern Ireland, which were completed about five years ago. There are also separate building regulations for Scotland, so we should know how long it took for them to be produced. At least the Scots have the advantage of being a long way away from the main building of England. From where I stand, I hope that Her Majesty’s Government will have a little more thought about passing this burden—and I believe that it is a burden—to the Welsh Assembly. The second order seems to be largely technical and administrative and a tidying-up exercise. I have no particular comments to add to the Minister’s explanation of it.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
713 c5-7GC 
Session
2008-09
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Children Devolved matters Administration of justice Company law Costs Conservation British nationality Buildings Devolution Building regulations Civil servants Housing Energy Legislative competence National Assembly for Wales Ministers Prices Standards Wales Tourism Supreme Court Welsh Government Energy performance certificates
Legislation
Government of Wales Act 2006 (Consequential Modifications, Transitional Provisions and Saving) Order 2009
Welsh Ministers (Transfer of Functions) (No. 2) Order 2009
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk