Proceeding contribution from Chris Leslie (Labour) in the House of Commons on Friday, 21 October 2011. It occurred during Debate on bill on Master's Degrees (Minimum Standards) Bill.
Master's Degrees (Minimum Standards) Bill
I beg to move, That the Bill be now read a Second time. This Bill would resolve a straightforward question—should some universities have the right to award a free master's degree, while at every other university hundreds of thousands of students have to work hard to earn theirs? It is difficult to believe, but the practice of converting a bachelor's degree into a master's without exams, extra study or tuition fees still exists. Only some 3,000 lucky bachelor's degree graduates of only two universities—Oxford and Cambridge—are able to list an impressive-looking postgraduate qualification on their CVs each year, for nothing more than a £10 administration charge, and without even the £10 fee at Cambridge. In what must rank as one of the most byzantine relics of a bygone era—other than private Member's Bill Fridays—these complimentary master of arts degrees require nothing more than a 21-term period to elapse after matriculation before these fortunate few graduates have their bachelor's degrees automatically upgraded. Neil Dodgson, a Cambridge professor, says that"““many find it offensive that we should award a degree for doing nothing more than being able to breathe for three years.””" In contrast, the vast majority of ordinary postgraduate students have to earn their degree the hard way, often paying a £4,500 or higher tuition fee, studying for a year or more, completing coursework, exams, dissertations, and so on. Many of those who earn their master's degrees are completely unaware that they could be competing for future employment with candidates declaring their MA(Oxon) or MA(Cantab) at the head of their CV. Is that really fair? Clearly not. Eleven years ago, the Quality Assurance Agency for Higher Education said:"““The Masters title causes much misunderstanding...most employers think it always represents an award for postgraduate study””." A survey the agency conducted found that more than 60% of recruiters were unaware of the honorary nature of this so-called higher degree. The time has come to end this anachronism, and a growing body of opinion believes it is time to draw a veil over these arrangements. I should state for the record that I do not blame anyone from Oxbridge for taking the opportunity presented to them—chance would be a fine thing. But if we set aside the cheeky sense of privilege, even the most battle-hardened defenders of elitism have to admit that the total and utter lack of merit behind this apparently great award is unfair. Indeed, it is now surely in the best interests of modern and open Oxford and Cambridge universities for them to voluntarily relinquish this privilege and prove that they are beacons of genuine learning and earned distinction. I have written to both universities challenging them to reconsider voluntarily and phase out these arrangements without the need for legislation. Unfortunately, they are gambling that no one will disturb their long-standing privileges. But there is still time and I hope that the Minister will join me in urging Oxford and Cambridge to take seriously the palpable objections to these give-away degrees. They undermine valid qualifications from other universities. They entrench an artificial distinction between students and higher education institutions. They confuse employers and create the risk that genuine achievements are misrepresented. They demoralise those who spend years of their lives to achieve something that others get for nothing. They risk devaluing the genuine calibre and reputation of British higher education. Some will argue that this is a harmless practice and that everyone knows that it is not really a masters degree. Unfortunately, however, not everyone is in the loop, and plenty of people will be hoodwinked by the free degree. I could argue that one solution is to allow everyone with a bachelor's degree the same chance to get a free master's thrown in, but that would be daft. Instead, I propose a simple, and surely uncontentious Bill. It would require the Quality Assurance Agency to report within three months on the measures necessary to establish a minimum standard—a very minimum standard—of academic achievement for all master's degrees awarded by higher education institutions in England. Hon. Members may be surprised to learn that there are no basic or fundamental yardsticks of that sort to ensure academic rigour across the board, but sadly that is the case. A simple threshold would ensure that future postgraduate degrees are all awarded on the basis of the proven hard work of students who have undertaken a course of study. Basic standards and fair play should not be too much to ask. The time has come for us to end this unmerited and confusing patronage once and for all.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 533 c1236-7
- Session
- 2010-12
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Commons chamber
- Subjects
- University of Cambridge Degrees Graduates University of Oxford Qualifications Standards Universities Trinity College Dublin
- Legislation
- Master's Degrees (Minimum Standards) Bill 2010-12
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2023-12-15 13:24:50 +0000
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_775996
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_775996
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_775996