---

Living Standards

I am grateful to the right hon. Gentleman for intervening, because I asked him the question when he was speaking, and he said that he opposed cuts for people who are out of work and that he opposed cuts for people who are in work. When I asked him whom that left, he said nothing—he never answers the question—and his Back Benchers said, ““The bankers””. He was in the Treasury when, before the general election, the Labour Government introduced a ““temporary”” bankers' bonus tax. If Labour thought they were going to win the election, why did they not make the bankers' bonus tax permanent? It was a one-off, pre-election gimmick, whereas this Government have introduced a banking levy that, every year, will raise more than his temporary banking tax raised in any year.