Skip to main content

Commons Briefing paper by Patrick Butchard, John Curtis and Philip Loft. It was first published on Wednesday, 30 September 2026. It was last updated on Tuesday, 10 November 2026.


UK-Argentina tensions on the Falklands Islands and oil 2026

In September 2026, the Argentine President, Javier Milei, restated Argentina’s long-standing claim to the Falklands Islands, a UK Overseas Territory with 3,600 British citizens that Argentina refers to as Islas Malvinas.

President Milei also said that Argentina would:

  1. begin action in international courts if activity at the Sea Lion oil field (to the north of the Falklands) does not cease. Initial proceedings on the request for provisional measures by the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea will be held on 10 and 11 November 2026
  2. apply sanctions against those engaged in the oil field’s exploitation,
  3. resume work on a naval base in the south of the country.

These are not the first actions Argentina has taken in opposition to the Sea Lion oil field, having announced sanctions and other restrictions in the 2010s. It has previously accused the UK of “unilateral” action on the field, in breach of a UN General Assembly resolution (these are generally not binding).  

The UK and Falkland Islands Governments have set out long-standing positions that the Falkland Islanders have a right to self-determination, wish to remain British, and the territory has the right to exploit the oil field. The UK Government has said it will contest the legal case and is introducing protections for businesses engaged in the Falklands.

This briefing introduces the competing claims to the Islands, the actions of the Argentine Government and response of the UK and Falklands in 2026, and statements of President Trump that the US position is “under review”.

What are the competing views on the Falklands/Islas Malvinas?

The governments of Argentina and the UK disagree on the status of the Islands. Argentina argues the Falkland Islands (Islas Malvinas) are part of its territory, as the successor state to the Spanish empire, while the UK stresses the right of self-determination of the Falklands population. No international court has ruled on the dispute. The below provides a summary of the two positions.

UK position: Right of self-determination

The UK argues that the Falkland Islanders have the right to self-determination under the UN charter, and there will be no negotiations on sovereignty unless the Islanders support it.

Articles 1 and 55 of the UN Charter state all countries should respect the “principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples”. The right is also set out in Article 1 of both the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, stating “all peoples” can “freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development”.

Argentina argues the right to self-determination does not apply; President Milei told the UN General Assembly in September 2026 that “the population [Falkland Islanders] was implanted by the occupying power on a territory whose sovereignty is in dispute”. The UK says there was no permanent or indigenous population at the time of British settlement in 1833.

Argentine governments have also argued that the principle of self-determination “must not be used as an excuse for violating the territorial integrity of existing states”.

Argentine position: Territorial integrity

Argentina claims sovereignty through inheritance, upon independence, of Spain’s possessory title (“uti possidetis”) to the Islands, as in place in 1810 (the process of Argentine independence, achieved in 1816, beginning that year).

As noted in the Max Planck Encyclopaedias of International Law, the status of “uti possidetis” was not universally recognised in the nineteenth century and can be in tension with the principle of self-determination.

The Argentine position is that Spanish claims to the Islands were first made in 1767, with the purchase of a French settlement, established three years previously. Spanish/Argentine activity, in different forms, continued until 1833.

The UK position is the UK claimed sovereignty in 1765 and while a settlement was withdrawn in 1774, sovereignty claims continued and administration was resumed in 1833 and UK control has been continuous since, save for during the 1982 conflict.   

What have UN resolutions said on the Falklands?

UN General Assembly (UNGA) resolutions, unlike those of the UN Security Council, are non-binding if making recommendations to states (as under articles 10 to 14 of the UN charter). The UN has not resolved the question of sovereignty.

Several UNGA resolutions have called for the UK and Argentina to enter negotiations to settle the future of the Falklands peacefully (for example, UNGA resolution 2065 (1965, PDF) and UNGA resolution 3160 (1973, PDF)).

These call for negotiations to take into account UNGA resolution 1514 (1960, on granting independence to colonial countries and peoples) and the interests of the population of the Islands.

UNGA resolution 3149 (1976, PDF) additionally “calls upon” the UK and Argentina to “refrain from taking decisions that would imply introducing unilateral modifications in the situation while the islands are going through the process” of negotiation.

Argentina’s president has referred to the latter resolution as a reason why work on the Sea Lion oil field should cease and said the UN should do more to ensure negotiations take place under the UNGA framework.

However, the UK Government says the UNGA votes “do not modify or dilute […] the legally binding right of self-determination” under the UN Charter or prohibit economic development by the Islanders.

The Falklands and South Georgia and South Sandwich Islands

Map of the South Atlantic showing the Falklands/Malvinas

Source: © OpenStreetMap Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 2.0 license (CC BY-SA 2.0).

What steps has Argentina announced in 2026?

In a national address in September 2026 (link in Spanish), President Javier Milei set out four actions Argentina will take on the Falkland Islands.

This followed an earlier statement in April 2026 made to mark the anniversary of the start of the Falklands conflict in 1982, in which the president said Argentina would use “all necessary diplomatic measures” to achieve a “peaceful and definitive solution” to the dispute.

1)     Restating Argentina’s claim

The president restated Argentina’s claim to the Falklands, the UK’s presence as “colonial”, and the islanders not having the right to self-determination.

He also reiterated transitional article 1 of Argentina’s constitution, which says that a “permanent and unwaivable objective of the Argentine people” is “regaining” the “Malvinas, South Georgia and Sandwich Islands” (referring to the UK’s other Overseas Territory in the region).

President Milei cited a potential change in the US position (see the end of this briefing) and said his country would be a “reliable ally” to the US in the southern hemisphere.

2)   Planning new economic sanctions

The Argentine president said he would expand sanctions against companies that are participating in the exploitation of the oil field near the Territory (see below).

In September, the Argentine Government began sanctions proceedings against 60 people and companies engaged in oil exploration.

Argentina is also planning further sanctions legislation, though Argentine media reports suggest US administration concern on the negative impact of sanctions in 2026 has resulted in the government slowing progress on the legislation.

3)    Continuing Argentine naval base construction

The president also said he would prioritise construction of the Ushuaia naval base, in Tierra del Fuego, the southernmost province of Argentina.

Construction had begun in 2022, but limited progress has been made since. It is expected to be completed by 2029.

Despite the announced action, a spokesperson for the president has said the sovereignty claim is “diplomatic, peaceful, not military.”

4)   Threatening international legal action  

In September, the Argentine Government also announced it would bring a case against the UK under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.

Public proceedings on the case will be held in November 2026—see below.

How new is the Argentine campaign?

Milei’s predecessor as Argentine president, Alberto Fernández, had previously launched a campaign on the Islands, known as the “Agenda Malvinas 40 years” campaign, in 2022.

In 2023, he withdrew Argentina from a ten-point 2016 agreement with the UK, and called for a resumption of sovereignty talks. The agreement had included plans to restart high-level government to government talks, addressing corruption and organised crime globally, promoting educational and cultural links, and to identify fallen Argentine soldiers buried on the Falklands.

The sanctions planned in 2026 are not the first announced against the oil field, with Argentine actions since 2010 including restrictions on ships travelling from Argentina to the Territory in 2010, passing a law to allow for prison sentences and fines against those supporting oil exploration in 2013, and sanctions against companies engaged in the oil field.

What is the Sea Lion Oil Field?

The Sea Lion oil field are around 130 miles to the north of the Falklands, and operated by Navitas Petroleum and Rockhopper Exploration. Both have previously been disqualified from working in Argentina.

The field has an estimated 319 million barrels of oil and are expected to produce their first oil in 2028, once further licences are issued. Previous work had been halted due to falls in oil prices.

The field is expected to be a major source of revenue for the Falklands Government and help diversify an economy where fisheries represent most economic activity (PDF).

What role does the UK have in approving the field?

Hydrocarbons licences require the consent of a UK Secretary of State, who acts in accordance with Falkland Islands legislation (the Falkland Islands Offshore Minerals Ordinance 1994). The UK Government does not comment on individual licences.

Will the field contribute to UK emissions?

The Falklands is not subject to the UK Government’s oil and gas policy.

The Territory’s emissions do not count towards UK Carbon Budgets or the Net Zero target under the Climate Change Act 2008.

The UK Government will extend the Paris Agreement on Climate Change to the Falklands only with the Falkland Islands Government’s consent.

The Territory’s environmental strategy (PDF) says it is currently exploring setting targets on carbon neutrality.

Has there been past agreement with Argentina to exploit the field?

Argentina and the UK previously had an agreement for oil exploration around the Territory from 1995.

However, in 2007, Argentina withdrew from the agreement, saying the UK was acting unilaterally in granting licences for exploration, in breach of UN resolutions (see above).

President Milei made the same argument in his September 2026 speech. In response to the 2007 announcement, the UK Government had said Argentina’s action “makes future co-operation in this area more difficult”.

What’s the domestic context in Argentina?

Javier Milei took office as President in December 2023 for a four-year term, promising to make significant cuts to government spending to tackle hyper-inflation and liberalise economic policy.

Economic policy successes such as lowering very high inflation and increasing economic growth boosted his popularity and helped produce a strong performance in the October 2025 parliamentary elections. However, in 2026 corruption scandals, internal party rifts and a stuttering economy have led to a reduction in President Milei’s popularity compared to 2024 and 2025.

The next Presidential elections are due in October 2027 and currently President Milei’s La Libertad Avanza coalition is tied with the main opposition Homeland Force coalition in polls. The Financial Times also report that President Milei is facing a potential 2027 electoral challenge “from his estranged vice-president Victoria Villarruel, a pro-military activist for whom the Falklands are a flagship issue”.

What legal action has Argentina begun?

On 28 September, the Argentine Government announced it would bring a case against the UK under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) if the “illegitimate” Sea Lion project was not stopped within two weeks.

While the venue and court for the main arbitration will be determined in future, the preliminary stages of the case are underway before the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea, which will consider any provisional measures.

What court might hear the full case?

Under UNCLOS, Argentina and the UK have selected different courts as their preferred method of resolving disputes under the convention.

The UK has chosen the International Court of Justice (ICJ) as the forum for settling disputes under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, according to its Declaration to UNCLOS of 12 January 1998.  Argentina has selected the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea (ITLOS).

Where two states disagree on the forum for a dispute (namely, if the UK prefers the ICJ and another state seeks to use ITLOS), the rule according to UNCLOS Article 287(5) is that the dispute may be solved via binding arbitration under Annex VII of UNCLOS, unless the parties agree on an alternative.

What has Argentina requested?

Until the arbitration is set up (which can take some time), the states could request binding provisional measures from ITLOS until the arbitral tribunal is constituted. Argentina requested such provisional measures from ITLOS on 13 October 2026. In its request, Argentina requested the tribunal impose the following measures (PDF):

  • that the UK prevent the Sea Lion project from commencing or continuing “the exploitation of hydrocarbon resources”
  • that the UK refrain from using any discoveries in the exploration operations to the detriment of Argentina
  • that the UK allow Argentina to “protect and preserve the marine environment” in the areas subject to the dispute
  • that the UK does not grant any new permits for the exploitations of natural resources of the disputed areas.

Argentina’s main claims beyond provisional measures are set out in the ITLOS press release (PDF) and in Argentina’s formal request (PDF). Argentina alleges that the UK is breaching its obligations, in particular:

  • the need to respect for Argentina’s sovereignty and rights under UNCLOS (with Argentina claiming Argentina as the ‘coastal state’ for maritime rights under UNCLOS)
  • the exploring and exploiting natural resources in a maritime zone that is subject to a decolonisation dispute
  • the prevention of Argentine from “fulfilling its duties” to protect and preserve the marine environment in the disputed waters
  • the settling of disputes peacefully and in good faith.

Will questions of sovereignty and sea boundaries be determined?

Disputes under UNCLOS do not consider questions of sovereignty, because courts or tribunals only have jurisdiction on the interpretation and application of matters within UNCLOS itself (see Article 288, UNCLOS).

States can also limit the jurisdiction for specific types of dispute outlined in Article 298 of UNCLOS. Both Argentina and the UK have declared that they do not accept jurisdiction over disputes relating to “sea boundary delimitations, or those involving historic bays or titles”.

In its submission, Argentina does not specifically claim a dispute over these issues but instead seeks to claim Argentina is already the “coastal state” for the purposes of UNCLOS. Some cases that have included sovereignty disputes under “coastal state” claims have limited their consideration of claims to states’ obligations for the protection of the marine environment.

How has the UK responded?

The UK Government says it will engage with the process and delivered a response to Argentina’s notification on 11 October 2026. It says it will not provide a “running commentary” on the case but will “robustly” defend UK and Falkland interests.

How has the UK Government responded in 2026?

The government has said the Falkland Islanders have the right to self-determination, and it would reiterate this in diplomatic discussions. It has announced measures to protect businesses engaged with the Falklands and says it is keeping other steps, such as sanctions, under review.

Right of self-determination and diplomacy

In response to an urgent question in the House of Commons on 8 September 2026, Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) Minister, Kirsty McNeill, said there was “no doubt that the Falkland Islands are British for as long as they want to be” and the recent Argentine statements would not affect the UK’s “unwavering commitment”.

The Conservatives, Liberal Democrats and Reform have also backed the position. The Shadow Foreign Secretary, Tom Tugenhat, has suggested the UK block Argentina’s application to the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), if Argentine actions continue.

In response to a question whether the UK could use its CPTPP membership to block the current Argentine application, the government has said it will “consider all appropriate mechanisms” and would not comment publicly on CPTPP discussions.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has also spoken to President Trump on the Falkland Islands, telling him in September that “Britain would stand firm in the face of threats”. He also set out this position to the UN General Assembly.

The Minister for Latin America, Chris Elmore, has also “made clear” the UK’s position in a meeting with the Argentine ambassador to the UK on 17 September. The government says it is also raising the issue within the G7 and G20 groups of states and with European and South American governments.

UK Government protection for businesses

On 18 September, the Minister for the Overseas Territories (OT), Uma Kumaran, published a statement to coincide with new guidance on doing business with the Falklands. She said the Islanders “have the right to develop their natural resources as they see fit” and the government “stands fully behind those businesses and individuals” engaged in the Falklands.

In October, the UK Government said it was further preparing measures under Protection of Trading Interests (PTI) legislation to “prevent UK persons from complying with specific extraterritorial sanctions measures” introduced by Argentina on the Falklands. The Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade sets out how PTI measures function.

“Letters of comfort” (referring to undertakings of support, but not legally binding) have also been issued to some companies.

What military assets does the UK have in the Falklands?

The Defence Secretary, Wes Streeting, told the Sun newspaper in September that Argentina “lack[s] the ability to take the Falklands” but the UK does have the capacity to defend them.

The OT Minister, Uma Kumaran, has said that UK military forces in the Territory are “maintained at the appropriate level to ensure the defence […] against any potential threat”.

Army, naval and air capabilities are maintained in the Falklands. Current assets in the South Atlantic include HMS Medway. Replacement Tranche 2 Typhoon aircraft are expected in late 2027 when earlier models are retired.

How has the Falkland Islands Government responded?

The Falkland Islands is largely self-governing outside foreign and defence affairs, with a locally-elected legislature. In September 2026 the chair of the Legislative Assembly, Jack Ford, said that “claims of this kind [from Argentina] have been made against the Falkland Islands many times over many years” and were “nothing new”.

He also referenced the 2013 referendum held on the Islands on whether it should remain a UK Overseas Territory, and in which 1,513 of 1,517 voters (on a 90% turnout) backed doing so.

Since the Argentine measures were announced in September, the Territory Government has announced an extension of the length for all existing offshore hydrocarbons production licences. The Falklands Government said this had “the full support of the UK Government”.

What has President Trump said in 2026?

The historic US position has been one of neutrality on the dispute.

In response to a question in September 2026 on whether the US is reviewing its position on the Territory, President Trump said that he “always reviews every position” and it was “one of many” being reviewed.

In a separate event in September, the president said that “right now we have two countries that are not happy” over the Falklands and “I’m sure I’d be called into that potential disaster” if tensions increased. He said he would “probably be able to settle […] it out”.

President Trump and President Milei have been close political allies and the USA had provided financial support to the Argentine Government in 2025.

Further reading on the sovereignty dispute


Secondary information

Type
Research briefing
Reference
CBP-12216 
Subjects
British overseas territories Falkland Islands Foreign relations Oil Offshore industry Sovereignty International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea Diplomatic relations Negotiations USA UN resolutions Sanctions Argentina UN Convention on the Law of the Sea Self-determination of states Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership Milei, Javier
Published by
International Affairs and Defence Section
House of Commons Library
Link
View this Research briefing on commonslibrary.parliament.uk