Proceeding contribution from Baroness Butler-Sloss (Crossbench) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 29 January 2008. It occurred during Committee proceeding and Debate on bill on Child Maintenance and Other Payments Bill.
Child Maintenance and Other Payments Bill
I have put my name to the three amendments. There is no definition of parenting in any primary or secondary legislation. It is to be found in a number of cases in the Court of Appeal and in occasional cases in the House of Lords. However, they are not instantly available to most people, particularly not to those who are involved in the unhappy breakdown of their relationship, whether it is a marriage or a partnership. There are practical reasons, in addition to those given by my noble friend Lord Northbourne—I agreed entirely with every word he said—why having a definition in this legislation would be very helpful. First, in a large number of cases, the money to be paid to children is not the only issue to come before a court or has to be discussed by a mediator or by lawyers in cases where lawyers are involved. When a couple separates, it is usual to look at whether the house or flat is rented or owned and whether the children are to see the non-resident parent—usually the father. Contact is extremely difficult to manage if the mother does not have an assurance that the father will pay. Technically, money and contact are totally separate issues, but as a matter of human reality, the mother usually says, ““If you are to see your child, what are you going to pay?””. In cases such as those referred to by my noble friend Lord Northbourne, where the parent—usually the man but not always—does not see why he should pay, there is nothing to point to other than the fact that he should pay because the legislation says that he must. However, there is the important concept that both parents have responsibility for their child and that part of sharing that responsibility is to pay. There is no question but that the mother, as the primary carer, will pay, because usually the money given by a father is not enough to support a child. Therefore, it is very important that the non-resident parent who is asked to pay under legislation is also made fully aware of the concept of the obligation of responsibility. I wish to make two practical points. If there are lawyers or mediators in the case, they could say, ““You are expected to be responsible, as is shown in the legislation””. My noble friend Lord Northbourne and I are hoping to include this in the Children and Young Persons Bill. We want it to be set out clearly across the board that there is responsibility in payment and responsibility in the care of children. Perhaps more importantly, many of these fathers—they are generally fathers—do not have lawyers and will not be in discussion with the mother’s lawyer, if she has one. However, almost certainly a court will be dealing with the separated couple and, after they have separated, will pick up the pieces for them in relation to the rented flat or the owned house and the contact arrangements and so on. Whether it is someone in the magistrates’ court, the district judge or occasionally the circuit judge, he can point to this legislation and say that it really matters. He will say not simply, ““You’ve got to pay because the legislation says so””, but, ““You have got to be responsible for your children””. The meaning of ““responsibility”” is set out in Amendment No. 35. We need Parliament to make a statement in primary legislation that responsible parenting matters a great deal in relation to money, children and everything that goes with the breakdown of the relationship between parents. Even in a case such as my noble friend Lord Northbourne described, where a father says that he did not intend to have children, he has a responsibility under the Child Support Act and this legislation and he needs to be told as well as anyone else that it is not just a money matter. The child is born and the grown-ups have to be responsible for that child. It is the issue of responsibility that my noble friends Lord Northbourne, Lady Finlay and I are extremely keen to push forward. Although one may think that this is all a bit of a concept and rather vague, I have to tell noble Lords that, having been a lawyer and a judge, I would have been helped, as other judges will be helped, by having this in primary legislation.
Secondary information
- Type
- Proceeding contribution
- Reference
- 698 c316-7GC
- Session
- 2007-08
- Chamber / Committee
- House of Lords Grand Committee
- Subjects
- Staff ICT Children Conditions of employment Debts Age Absent parents Child Support Agency Maintenance Parents Standards Child Maintenance and Enforcement Commission
- Legislation
- Child Maintenance and Other Payments Bill 2006-07 to 2007-08
- Link
- View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk
Librarians' tools
- Timestamp
- 2026-10-23 12:27:49 +0100
- URI
- http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_440058
- In Indexing
- http://indexing.parliament.uk/Content/Edit/1?uri=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_440058
- In Solr
- https://search.parliament.uk/claw/solr/?id=http://data.parliament.uk/pimsdata/hansard/CONTRIBUTION_440058