Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Patel of Blackburn (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 29 April 2008. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Health and Social Care Bill.


Health and Social Care Bill

I remind the Committee that I have an interest as chairman of the Mental Health Act Commission. I am encouraged by the Minister's previous expression of openness towards further discussions on the question of service-user, carer and general public involvement, especially in the work of the Care Quality Commission. I have put my name to Amendment No. 27, which I think sets out duties for such involvement in a meaningful way. It is, at least, a great improvement on the Bill's construction as presented, which only requires the CQC to ““consider the views”” of service users and others. A duty to consider the views of service users may be too easily met by consultation, rather than involvement, as many noble Lords have pointed out. I would want an organisation that is required to have service users at its heart, not on its periphery. The Minister has previously paid tribute to the Mental Health Act Commission's service-user reference panel, as have other Members of the Committee on a previous amendment. The Mental Health Act Commission has always had service users among its membership, but in recent years it has made particular efforts to involve service users who are or have recently been detained, which has had a huge impact on all aspects of the organisation, not just on the visiting programme. Last week, we published a report which I know has been sent to the Minister. The involvement of service users is something that everyone is keen on but, if the truth is told, very few organisations do it well. Many do little other than consult their service users. Consultation is, of course, a good start but it does not go far enough; it does not engage people in any meaningful way. In my experience and in the experience of the Mental Health Act Commission, real service-user engagement is very challenging. It involves a huge number of risks that managers and staff have to take. It requires resourcing which includes not only staff time—named individuals who take the work forward—but also sufficient funds to undertake the work. Only when the Mental Health Act Commission has put in those resources and individuals to do that work will a real impact have been made. It requires understanding and commitment from the whole organisation. People need to be trained and they need to own the vision. That should not be an add-on or an extra but at the heart of what it does. It is very challenging and should be underpinned by some systematic and proactive approach. We tend to be very reactive when things happen, but we do not have a systematic approach to dealing with this. They are the key elements of what needs to happen. The rewards are significant. True engagement with effective service-user and carer involvement enables us to understand who people are in all their complexity. It is a truism, but important none the less, that services would not exist if people did not require help, support and treatment. The service exists for the service user. Sadly, that may not always be obvious, but it is the service user who is the expert, for example, on how it feels to be detained against his or her will; to be denied many things that we might take for granted in our day-to-day lives; to be treated with powerful psychotropic medication. Service-user involvement is not a luxury to be added when we have the basics right. It is the basics. The Care Quality Commission must be able to draw on that experience and expertise, to tailor its visits to those matters that service users themselves identify and to ensure that the civil legal and human rights of patients are upheld at all times. It is essential to the current government agenda of increasing personal choice and ensuring that services are responsive to individual need and that they start to become user-led. The really important point is that the Care Quality Commission must be a leader in this if it wants to inspect how others develop service user and carer engagement. It needs to set the benchmark. It needs to get its own house in order and show the way forward as regards principles of equality and engagement and inspecting others. For too long, professionals, academics, practitioners and managers have retained sole control of organisational priorities. I would want to see the CQC’s technical commitment to service-user and carer involvement fully on board so that this becomes one of the key drivers of policy development and implementation at every level. We can see the evidence of this in the Mental Health Act Commission, where service-user involvement is not only about having an effect on the patients that it visits, but about changing the culture of the organisation. Commissioners who work alongside service users have reported that experience influences the way in which they carry out their duties. It is important that this cultural shift is preserved by the CQC’s monitoring of psychiatric compulsion and that service-user and carer involvement is entrenched in every aspect of its work, too. I hope that that will be emulated across the CQC, and in support of that aim I support the amendment.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
701 c17-8GC 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Complaints Disability Care homes Carers Health services Human rights Inspections NHS Patients Pay Public appointments Public participation Patients' rights Mental health services Standards Social services Care Quality Commission Local involvement networks
Legislation
Health and Social Care Bill 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk