Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Campbell-Savours (Labour) in the House of Lords on Tuesday, 29 April 2008. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Health and Social Care Bill.


Health and Social Care Bill

I do not come to this debate as a professional in this area; my knowledge is very limited. My experience outside the institution of Parliament is in engineering, and I am more used to dealing with milling machines, capstan lathes, plating plants, pressings and trade exhibitions. I come almost as a virgin to this debate. I support the thrust of the amendment proposed by the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, but I want to speak to Amendment No. 104, proposed by the noble Baroness, Lady Meacher, which to me is particularly significant. It says: "““Entry and inspection: lay inspectors (1) Persons authorised by the Commission to enter and inspect any premises shall include lay inspectors. (2) In this section "lay inspectors" means persons not trained in the profession or employed in the service being inspected””." I am one of those people. I want to explain why I think that is very important. Prior to placing my mother in a nursing home, I visited 19 homes, some of which, I presume, had been the subject of inspections, and which were absolutely appalling. Half of them, to put it bluntly, stank of urine when I went into them. Those were homes which, under the current inspection regime, somehow cleared the hurdle of acceptability. There was one particular home, not very far from this institution of Parliament, in which I would not have kept an animal. The fees were over £1,000 per week. There were more than 30 residents in the home. That is the real world that goes on outside, and when people like me, who have very little knowledge in these sorts of areas, are confronted with a decision to place someone in a home, to put it bluntly, we wonder what the hell is going wrong and how homes such as that one manage to clear the hurdle. If it is that the professionals are prepared to put up with that standard of care, it is about time that lay persons had some rights in these issues and had a right to influence events. I positively endorse the amendment proposed by the noble Baroness, Lady Meacher. In my view, that amendment would probably make a major contribution to dealing with the problems with which I was confronted when visiting those homes. If I were a lay inspector, and I found homes stinking of urine, as I did—Monday mornings can be difficult in homes—and if during the balance of a week you are confronted by the smell of urine when you go into a home, I would want action. To this day I do not understand how that is allowed to go on. I toured the rooms in one home, which, presumably, had cleared its inspections under the current regime. Under the diluted arrangements that we are going to introduce, I cannot imagine how bad it will be. As I went around that home, clients were lying semi-naked on beds with the doors open, and I could see in as I passed those rooms. The rooms were dilapidated and undecorated. The beds were iron framed, which reminded me of when I was away at school in the 1950s. For that kind of conditions, there were huge fees—some were far in excess of £1,000 per week—to which I shall turn in a later amendment. However, I should like to say that the home I have found for my mother is excellent. The homes to which I am referring are finding a clientele. I wonder what families are placing their loved ones in these homes. How often are people visiting these homes? Are they simply dumping their families and oblivious to the fact that conditions are bad because they have never regularly inspected them themselves? It is not a question of the people going into these homes having rights, because very often they are beyond the capability of understanding the conditions in which they have been placed. This whole area needs a major shake-up. Based on my experience, I hope that this Bill gives us the opportunity to bring about the changes in which I very strongly believe.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
701 c19-20GC 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Complaints Disability Care homes Carers Health services Human rights Inspections NHS Patients Pay Public appointments Public participation Patients' rights Mental health services Standards Social services Care Quality Commission Local involvement networks
Legislation
Health and Social Care Bill 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk