Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Richard Bacon (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Thursday, 23 October 2008. It occurred during Debate on Public Accounts.


Public Accounts

It is a great pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Southport (Dr. Pugh), who is a forensic member of the Public Accounts Committee; his contributions are always appreciated by its members, of whichever party. I endorse the Chairman of the Committee's comments about public expenditure, and the recent bank recapitalisation, in particular. It is entirely appropriate for the Comptroller and Auditor General to examine the huge sum involved on behalf of taxpayers, and I very much hope that the Treasury agrees with that and will assist the National Audit Office in every way. Secondly, I wish to comment on the issue of financial management, which has been to the fore in many of the Committee's reports. When I first starting asking what proportion of principal finance officers—finance directors, as they are now called—in Departments have an accountancy qualification, the answer was 23 per cent. The Treasury recently told us that the answer is now 91 per cent, and although that figure excludes the big exception of the Ministry of Defence's finance director, who is in charge of £32 billion of expenditure, enormous progress has been made. I congratulate the Treasury and other Departments on starting to realise that the topic is important and that they have to do something about it. The progress should not go unremarked; the Treasury has understood the importance of the matter. That makes it all the more important for the Treasury to give a sensible account of tax credits, the subject of the Committee's eighth report. It stated that"““there is little evidence the Department has the scheme””—" the tax credits scheme—"““under control. Many claimants continue to struggle to understand tax credits and why they are overpaid. There have been many complaints about the process for recovering overpayments and the Ombudsman continues to receive and to uphold a large number of complaints…This level of error led the C&AG to qualify his opinion on the HMRC Trust Statement for the fifth year running. The Department still has no targets for reducing error and fraud.””" If we think that financial management is important, and if the Treasury thinks it is important enough to ensure that qualified finance directors are in place across Whitehall, surely it is important enough to ensure that the department that comes directly under the Treasury's own control—Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs, which has the task of collecting the money that we then spend on various public expenditure programmes—is itself under sufficiently tight financial management that it can account for how it spends its money. At the moment, it is unable to do so—it has not been able to do so for several years. I hope that we will be told when the Treasury expects the Comptroller and Auditor General to be able to sign off HMRC's accounts as clean, because it is only right that what is good for other Departments should be good for the Treasury and its subsidiary departments. I wish to make another quick point about tax credits. A settlement was reached between EDS and HMRC concerning the tax credits fiasco. The Treasury originally claimed that EDS should pay it £209 million, but that was later cut to an agreed settlement figure of £71 million. Only about £44 million of that was paid in cash or near cash, the remainder, £26.5 million, was to come from future revenues on contracts that EDS had not yet won with government. In other words, it is to come from future business. Apart from the fact that that gave Government Departments a rather strong incentive to award EDS further business despite, rather than because of, its track record, it has been clear that over the past two and half to three years since the agreement was reached hardly any money has been paid. Most of the £26.5 million is still unpaid; a few hundreds of thousands have been paid and there was one payment of £20,000. The chairman of HMRC for the time being knows that every time he comes before the Committee—unfortunately, I was abroad when he came before us last time, in early October—I shall ask him how much money he has had. He always comes prepared with the answer. Indeed, his distinguished predecessor Paul Gray, who honourably resigned over the issue of the missing discs, said that he would have been most disappointed had the question not been asked. I will continue to ask the question.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
481 c506-7 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Cost effectiveness Costs Banks Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs Budgets Finance Investment Government departments Financial markets Government shareholding Privatisation Public sector Public expenditure Private finance initiative Nationalisation National Audit Office Public private partnerships Ministry of Defence Taxation Committee of Public Accounts Risk assessment QinetiQ Office of Government Commerce Capital markets Olympic Games 2012
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk