Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Duke of Montrose (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 17 March 2010. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Flood and Water Management Bill.


Flood and Water Management Bill

My Lords, on behalf of my noble friend Lord Taylor of Holbeach, I shall speak to Amendments 4 and 6 in this group. I should declare an interest as a landowner, although not as one affected by this legislation. The first two clauses of this Bill spend time defining flood, erosion and risk in the most all-embracing terms that one can imagine—specifically, in terms of, ""human health … social and economic welfare … infrastructure, and … the environment"." We now move on to "risk management" and risk management functions. As far as I am aware, this is the first legislation to have the question of risk and safety brought into it and the first, in that regard, to deal with coastal erosion and flooding in general. As the Minister will be aware, it is not exactly the first in the case of dams and reservoirs. I declare an interest as the owner of a reservoir, which has been subject to the current inspection regime. Section 10(6) of the Reservoirs Act 1975 laid a duty on the inspecting engineer to report to the authority any recommendation that he might make to the undertaker of the reservoir of the action required in the interests of safety. In response to that, the Institution of Civil Engineers brought out its own guidelines, which were published in 1978 as Floods and Reservoirs Safety: An Engineering Guide. I am grateful to the institute for confirming all of this. At that date, it already took into consideration the risks to lives and properties downstream and came up with four categories of dams, which it labelled A, B, C and D, and the measures that should be applied to remedy each case. As your Lordships will see later, this Bill undertakes to redefine a "large raised reservoir" and allows that only those defined as "high-risk" reservoirs will be subject to inspection under the Bill. Does the Minister intend that a function of the risk management authority should be to define dams further, in categories similar to those presently employed by the Institution of Civil Engineers under the Reservoirs Act? If so, perhaps we could go into what implications there might be as we go further into the Bill. Returning to the amendments in this group, the Minister explained in his introduction that the Government have listened to the recommendations of your Lordships’ Delegated Powers and Regulatory Reform Committee, and that he has introduced his two amendments to curb the powers available to Ministers to change legislation by order. Noble Lords will be aware that this is a recurring theme, in Bill after Bill, and I congratulate your Lordships’ Committee on its persistent diligence in flagging up deficiencies in the drafting of Bills. There are a series of government amendments this afternoon, all of which also have opposition amendments grouped with them. We sought to push the Government into making their own changes and are pleased that they have done so. Our amendments add the express qualification that only existing statutory functions can be added to Clauses 4 and 5, and the Bill contains a fairly concise list of the statutory measures that can be included. The Committee has proposed that either the powers in the clauses be confined to statutory functions or they be subject to affirmative procedure. Our amendments follow the latter route, the Government’s the former. Is the Minister satisfied that this power cannot be extended to other Acts that might have a bearing in similar circumstances?


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
718 c236-7GC 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Agriculture Costs Coastal areas Coastal erosion Fees and charges Land Flood control Land drainage Inland waterways Emergency services Fire and rescue services Equipment Horticulture Floods National Assembly for Wales Water Voluntary organisations Wales Rural areas Urban areas Water companies Sewers Rescue services Reservoirs Social tariffs
Legislation
Flood and Water Management Bill 2009-10
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk