Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Campbell-Savours (Labour) in the House of Lords on Wednesday, 17 March 2010. It occurred during Debate on bill and Committee proceeding on Flood and Water Management Bill.


Flood and Water Management Bill

I was declaring an interest—I have to get my breath back because I have only one lung—as my former constituency included Cockermouth, Keswick and Workington. I am in contact with a lot of people up there who have been flooded. My amendment was originally moved in the Commons. It is about placing a clear statutory duty on fire and rescue services to deal with flooding incidents, thereby ensuring that they are properly equipped and trained. I am not arguing that they do not respond already. During the recent flooding in Cumbria, firemen went out of their way, showing great courage and determination, in their efforts to help those who were suffering, but they need proper support. These amendments would secure that objective. Why does the law need to be changed? In the view of many, particularly the Fire Brigades Union, the law at the moment is incoherent. Fire and rescue authorities have to plan for floods and have the power to respond, but do not have a duty to respond. The Civil Contingencies Act 2004 placed duties on fire and rescue authorities with respect to emergencies, including flooding. The duties include assessing the risks of emergencies and planning to prevent emergencies and to reduce, control or mitigate their effects. Of course, in reality, responding to flooding is a core function of the fire and rescue service and should therefore be treated as such. The public rightly expect firefighters and other professional emergency services to respond to flooding and other emergencies. During the 2007 floods, firefighters from scores of brigades outside the flooded areas responded to hundreds of incidents, rescuing more than 3,500 people during that period. The Pitt review recognised all this and therefore advocated a statutory duty. Recommendation 39 of the Pitt review stated that the Government should urgently put in place a fully funded national capability for flood rescue, with fire and rescue authorities playing a leading role, underpinned as necessary by a statutory duty. The Pitt review also noted how fire service personnel worked in difficult conditions, often using personal protective equipment designed for routine firefighting duties, or for infrequent short-duration incidents in rivers, lakes and canals. Fire crews were deployed in normal firefighting PPE rapidly became wet and cold, and risked contamination by flood water. The floods in Cumbria in November 2009 were a major test of existing arrangements. In Cumbria there were only 64 sets of swift water rescue personal protective equipment. I gained that information from the Fire Brigades Union magazine, Firefighter. The Fire Brigades Union in Cumbria reported that the crew trained to carry out swift water rescue was mobilised to pick up dry-suits and SWR equipment when the floods first kicked in but there was generally nothing for them to wear. During those first two safety-critical days that station could not carry out its rescue provision in water because it did not have any kit. The station does not have its own stand-alone supply of kit due to funding issues. There are 700 firefighters in Cumbria—200 whole-time, based at five stations, and 500 retained-duty firemen at 33 retained stations. Fire Brigades Union reps said that there were firefighters available for recalled duty who were never utilised due to the lack of equipment. The Fire Brigades Union has been trying to get better provision of equipment for the past two years, while retained members do not have satisfactory personal protective equipment to carry out the work that they have been doing. The Fire Brigades Union also reported that some boats did not have engines, while other engines had so little power that they struggled to operate in the conditions. I am sure noble Lords will know the relevance of the boats and engines that I refer to; they were shown on television throughout the period of the most recent flooding. The amendments that I am moving today were all moved in the Commons, although I have duplicated some of the amendments by placing them under an arrangement whereby they could be introduced to the legislation later by order. I do not know whether my noble friend has had time to see the revised amendments that were tabled yesterday. In the course of Commons proceedings, the Minister, Huw Irranca-Davies said: ""Fire and rescue authorities undoubtedly have a critical role to play in flood response, including flood rescue … That was shown to good effect in Cumbria, but I am interested in the comments of my hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington about the feedback that he has received"." There has obviously been much discussion between the union and Members of Parliament on the whole question of making this a statutory responsibility. Huw Irranca-Davies also said that the Government support Sir Michael’s recommendation that, ""a fully funded national capability for flood rescue should be put in place, with fire and rescue authorities playing a leading role, underpinned if necessary by a statutory duty". —[Official Report, Commons, 2/2/10; cols. 224-25.]" He went on to say: ""I want to make it clear, for my hon. Friend the Member for Hayes and Harlington"—" that is Mr John McDonnell— ""and for all those who have spoken in support in the amendment, that we do not reject totally the idea of a statutory duty option ‘if necessary’, as Sir Michael Pitt said. Our assessment at the moment is that that duty is not clearly needed right here and now, although we are already doing work in that direction".—[Official Report, Commons, 2/2/10; col. 225.]" The work they were doing was a project which co-ordinated a number of agencies in assessing their flood rescue capabilities. He then went on to say: ""My hon. Friend also raised the interesting point that an amendment could be introduced later in another place".—[Official Report, Commons, 2/2/10; col. 226.]" The amendment I have tabled would defer the requirement to introduce the statutory instrument subject to an order approved by each House. I hope my noble friend will respond positively, as I understand a number of Members of the other place will follow his comments with great interest. I beg to move.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
718 c241-3GC 
Session
2009-10
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand Committee
Subjects
Agriculture Costs Coastal areas Coastal erosion Fees and charges Land Flood control Land drainage Inland waterways Emergency services Fire and rescue services Equipment Horticulture Floods National Assembly for Wales Water Voluntary organisations Wales Rural areas Urban areas Water companies Sewers Rescue services Reservoirs Social tariffs
Legislation
Flood and Water Management Bill 2009-10
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk