Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Garnier (Conservative) in the House of Commons on Wednesday, 19 November 2008. It occurred during Debate on bill on Counter-Terrorism Bill.


Counter-Terrorism Bill

Although I frequently agree with the right hon. Member for Leicester, East (Keith Vaz), who is also my neighbour, the matters that we are dealing with today do not represent closure. By the very nature of the Government and the Home Secretary's production of the draft counter-terrorism temporary provisions Bill, in which clause 1(2) substitutes 42 days for 28 days, they are constantly reminding us that the Home Secretary found the decision of the other place to stick to 28 days rather than 42 days deeply disagreeable. The Home Secretary will not drop the bone. She will not let the matter go. She is behaving almost like Violet Elizabeth Bott rather than a rational Home Secretary. She refuses to see that she has lost the argument and she will go on stamping her feet. The draft Bill represents the stamping of her feet. I agree with the hon. Member for Walsall, North (Mr. Winnick) and all the others who advanced arguments against the 90 and 42-day limits. I have grave doubts about the 28-day limit, but that is the decision that both Houses of Parliament have arrived at. We ought to stick to that for the time being. It is tempting for a Government who have been defeated in the unelected House—a Government who managed to get the provision passed in the summer only by what I shall call an unusual majority, as I do not want to use unparliamentary language—to try to achieve their goal of a 42-day limit. I accept that politically and in terms of public relations such a defeat is very embarrassing and rather annoying, but it will not do for the Government to produce a moose under the table, as they say in Alaska—that is, what we used to call an elephant in the room—and to pretend that we cannot talk about it. The draft Bill is sitting in the Library and the Vote Office, partly as a threat and partly as a piece of Violet Elizabeth Bott-style spoiled child behaviour. Clause 22 of the Bill as it went to the other place, which has been knocked out by Lords amendment No. 4, defined something called a ““grave exceptional terrorist threat””. Such a threat meant"““an event or situation involving terrorism which causes or threatens…serious loss of human life…serious damage to human welfare in the United Kingdom, or…serious damage to the security of the United Kingdom.””" Such an event is the precise trigger that would get the draft Bill out of the Library. I urge the Government and the right hon. Member for Leicester, East to ensure that the draft Bill or the concepts that lie in it are thoroughly discussed in an inquiry by the Home Affairs Committee. Along with the right hon. Gentleman, I was a member of that Committee in the early 1990s and I seem to remember that, regardless of its party political majority, we discussed matters of serious importance to the home affairs remit in a collegiate fashion.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
483 c310-1 
Session
2007-08
Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamber
Subjects
Disclosure of information Databases Criminal records Crime prevention Crime Detainees Armed forces Death Banks Administrative delays Coroners Finance Juries Fingerprints Evidence Intelligence services Genetics Documents Legislation National security Personal records Police Powers Public interest Police custody Money laundering Parliamentary scrutiny Police interrogation Travel Terrorism Surveillance Remand in custody Police national computer Foreign travel orders Financial Action Task Force Freezing of assets
Legislation
Counter-terrorism Bill 2007-08
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk