Skip to main content

Proceeding contribution from Lord Freud (Conservative) in the House of Lords on Thursday, 25 November 2010. It occurred during Debate on Health and Safety: Common Sense Common Safety.


Health and Safety: Common Sense Common Safety

My noble friend will forgive me for not being able to answer him off the top of my head. I am not absolutely sure about how that abolition will happen. I will write to him and place a copy of the letter in the Library. My noble friend Lord German and the noble Lord, Lord McKenzie, asked about the SR settlement of the HSE and the reference to cuts among local authorities in this area. I hardly need to confirm that the HSE faces the kind of spending restraint that is seen in the rest of the public sector. Its current funding of £228.8 million will be reduced by 35 per cent over the SR period to around £150 million. The HSE is looking at how to maintain the position of health and safety in the country within that context and looking at its approach, and will report on how it will manage within that financial environment. My noble friend Lord German and the noble Lord, Lord Smith, observed that there was a lack of evidence in my noble friend Lord Young’s report. I think I can speak for him in saying that there was wide consultation with stakeholders in the course of his review. The noble Lord, Lord McKenzie, raised whether we are talking about reality or perception. My noble friend Lord Young’s report said that perception becomes reality at a certain point. The fact that people read silly health and safety myths in the media on a regular basis affects behaviour, has an impact and does not encourage a sensible and proportionate approach to risk. This dialogue about what is perception and what is reality does not properly take that point on board. Gold-plating was raised by my noble friends Lord German and Lord Vinson. It is at the heart of what the Government are doing in this area. We need to position health and safety as an enabler for business and citizens. The Government strongly support that approach. We know that it is central to the HSE’s new approach in the context of the financial rigours that we are facing. The noble Lords, Lord Smith and Lord Sugar, raised advertising. The claims management regulator has already agreed to look at the code regarding offering inducements and plans to close this loophole by April 2011. I am sure that the noble Lord, Lord Sugar, in particular, will welcome that assurance. My noble friend Lord Vinson and the noble Lord, Lord Rooker, talked about bureaucracy and the criminal records check system. The clearly excessive bureaucracy adds little to our real safety and has become part of the perception problem. Such checks fall outside the HSE’s remit, but I will bring the concerns on that to the attention of colleagues.


Secondary information

Type
Proceeding contribution
Reference
722 c1218-9 
Session
2010-12
Chamber / Committee
House of Lords chamber
Subjects
Compensation Codes of practice Advertising Accidents Conduct Bureaucracy Consultants Finance Inspections Liability Health and safety Health and Safety Executive Employers' liability Food Standards Agency Local government NHS Personal injury Negligence Offices Schools Small businesses Roads Shops Restaurants Snow and ice Ministry of Justice Conditional fee agreements Risk assessment Claims management services Adventure Activities Licensing Authority Health and Safety Laws Review
Link
View this Proceeding contribution on www.publications.parliament.uk